Columbia University ETP Program 2013 - page 39
by ARickli 118,098 Views | 392 Comments
The thread here for the Columbia University ETP program for entry in 2012 is pretty long (45 pages right now!), so I was hoping to elicit some of the same responses for those who are applying in 2013. Let's get to know each... Read More
- 0Mar 14, '13 by kesnurseHi ghostbird—nothing really specific from the FNP students, they just seemed generally happy with the program. My student ambassador said that a lot of the students who changed specialties after the ETP year moved into the FNP specialty, so maybe this is where some of the feelings of disorganization are coming from? FNP does seem significantly larger than the other specialties. Obviously these experiences are different for everyone, but I left visiting day feeling that I would be really supported at Columbia, by the faculty and by other students.
If you went to visiting day, I would email one of the FNP students who put their email addresses in the little booklet we received, I am sure they would help with some of your questions. If not, I am sure admissions can give you the email address of a current student. Good luck!
- 0Mar 15, '13 by rgracevnI've been frantically researching both Columbia and JHU the last few days. For peds it looks like this: At COlumbia you get 800 clinical hours, JHU only 600. JHU has a better ranking for undergrad nursing (#1) but Columbia is ranked higher in peds (#9 vs #12). JHU is cheaper and you are more prepared to work as a RN if you want to gain experience that way. Columbia is really more about getting to the MSN for people who don't really ever want to work as RNs. I guess my only concern at this point is will i be hirable as an NP without good RN experience? This is my thought process at the moment and still very conflicted. Have 11 hours to make that deposit! Sleep time.
- 0Mar 15, '13 by ghostbirdHopefulnurse, got your pm! Once I hit 15 posts I'll reply!
Rgracevn, I just got from a tour of JH and I have to say the surrounding area scared me quite a bit. Also, the program does seem to emphasize hospital nursing a lot, and since I'm FNP this doesn't appeal to me as much. But I was very impressed by the credentials of the professors. I'm still debating, but I think I may go with Columbia since the location is much safer and I get the sense that they place more importance on the MSN portion which is my endgame. I think NY will also have a more diverse patient population. Plus, the flexibility of switching into a different Masters track is pretty cool, just in case I change my mind. Let me know what you decide!
- 0Mar 16, '13 by rgracevnHey ghostbird, thanks for the info! I actually ended up putting my deposit down on Columbia today because I couldn't make up my mind and since I don't know what financial aid JH will offer I didn't want to lose my spot. I talked to a friend of a friend today for about an hour, she is currently in the JH ABSN Fall start, in her second semester. She gave me a lot of really honest insight. She said that she lives in a great neighborhood called Charles Village, that she says feel really safe and comfortable and she is from a small town in Oregon. She feels like she is getting the best nursing education possible...there are so many opportunities at JH and they split their 170 person class in half, whereas at Columbia we all get put into giant lecture halls with the full 180+ class. It really does come down to what your goal is and how fast your want to get there. NP is my endgame as well, but I talked to a Columbia ETP 2009 grad who ended up having to work as an RN for almost 3 years before she was eligible to apply to NP jobs...(at least in major cities, she thinks it would have been different if she had more more willing to go to rural areas or if she had stayed in NY and utilized her clinical contacts). She did peds and she wanted to work in hospitals. It could be different in a community/private clinic, I am not sure. I have heard from a lot of people that direct entry NP's should have a good amount (minimum 1 year) of RN experience under their belts if they want to get a good job, otherwise you basically end up starting out as a new RN, doing a new grad RN job with corresponding salary. JH would give a real nursing education, whereas Columbia kinda skips over that part with minimal clinical hours. On the other hand I LOVE the columbia peds program and am sort of uninspired by JH's. At this point if I get a scholarship from JH I will go there, work for a year or two and then apply to Columbia (+others) for peds programs. I just figure that if I am going to spend 100k on a bsn, I want to get the best education possible and have the best job prospects possible. Nursing is the foundation for the end goal...I am unsure that glossing over that is a good idea. I of course say all this and could totally end up (happily) at Columbia in May, I definitely think that they turn out competent NP's, but I know 2 ETP grads that felt they had a lot of catching up to do in nursing before they could start working as NPs. I'm head over heals for New York and have never been to Baltimore. Baltimore is supposed to be very diverse also right? They are both amazing programs, I'm just trying to figure out my priorities and the best way to make those happen. JH would take longer...unless you graduate from Columbia just to find that you have to take a job below your education level just to be hireable as an NP a year or two later. I'm sort of betting that it all evens out in the end...but I feel a lot better about that first $100k knowing that I really am getting the best nursing education and that I will be as prepared as possible, with amazing connections to get into an NP program I want afterwards. At least that's where I am at today...I could write a similar posting more in favor of Columbia tomorrow. It might come down to the fact that moving to NY from Oregon in less than 8 weeks seems crazy as I am sort of burnt out from pre-reqs and am looking forward to the summer : )
- 0Mar 16, '13 by rgracevnHey the healer's art. So I talked to a peds ETP grad the other day and she was telling me how much she absolutely loved the program. Things she said were amazing:clinical placements (very diverse, JH focuses on community health so there are no hospital rotations within the peds program). The director of the program ******* (she said as long as this woman is running the program I will be getting a great education); 800 clinical hours, whereas JH only offers 600, I think this is one of the main reasons that CU peds is ranked above JH peds;I think that the program of study/courses offered in peds at CU are better than those offered at JH. Besides there being more course work (= more clinical hours) which is obviously a pro for me, I am really interested in these particular classes: Advanced Pediatric and Neonatal Pharmacology, Emergency Pediatric Nursing, and Incorporating Genetics into Advanced Nursing Practice...I don't see anything comparable at JH. I eventually intend to end up in community health but I want the option of working in a hospital and I feel like JH doesn't really allow for that. Columbia also has sub-specialties and I am really interested in oncology and genetrics. However the faculty to student ratio at columbia is about 1:18 for both ETP year and MSN. Wheres JH is 1:7/8 for the BSN and for the MSN they say "Mentored patient care experiences based on the individual needs of the student are a cornerstone of the program." I am thinking this means one on one mentoring? Not sure. I think that no matter where we go, our first jobs will probably end up being where we did our clinicals. Its hard for RN's and NP's to find jobs without either a foot in the door or experience to back them up. I know that there will be no way for me to come back to Portland without at least one year of full time experience, the market here is completely saturated...even for OHSU students who seem to average 8-9 months to find their first RN jobs (within the city).
Are you still leaning Hopkins?
Last edit by Silverdragon102 on Mar 17, '13 : Reason: name removed as per Terms of Service
- 0Mar 17, '13 by the healer's artThanks for all the info on Columbia's peds program. I had no idea. It does sound pretty interesting.
Yes I am still leaning Hopkins (I didn't submit a deposit to Columbia). I did get into the BS/MS program but depending on how I like Hopkins I do have the option to apply to other programs for the Masters.
- 0Mar 18, '13 by ghostbirdRgracevn, Baltimore is diverse in the sense that the population is largely non-Caucasian but it is mostly African-American. I'd consider New York more diverse since a multitude of ethnicities are represented in the population (Caucausians, African-Americans, Asians, Europeans, Latin Americans, etc.) Since I am mostly interested in outpatient experiences, I focused a lot on the makeup of the local population.
I definitely suggest visiting Baltimore to see which city you find the most inspirational! After a few days in NYC, I felt like I owned the city whereas Baltimore made me retreat to my hotel room at 5 pm on my second day there...haha. And I know that would affect my learning ability/motivation. Of course it is all personal preference! I get the feeling that if you are really really into working with the extremely disadvantaged, Johns Hopkins would be your dream school. If I had a tougher stomach, I would love to go to Johns Hopkins. Between the amazing clinical rotations abroad, the chance to work with a very large indigent population, and with D.C. being only a short train ride away (think about the opportunities to get involved with politics!), Johns Hopkins seems like an amazing opportunity. However, I'm going with Columbia because I get the feeling that I would be much more inspired in NYC, and working abroad and working with the indigent are opportunities that I know that I can create for myself if I stay motivated. Plus it is pretty cool that Columbia has CAPNA! I think it would be a really cool experience to learn from the DNPs working there. In the end, each program has its upsides and downsides; it just depends on what gets you going!
- 0Apr 10, '13 by knurse16Hello future Columbia students,
I graduated from ETP in 2012 and am in the ETP-anesthesia program. When I first applied, I was admitted into the BSN portion (February 2011) but not the master's. Before starting the program, however, I was admitted into the CRNA portion of the program as well (April 2011). I didn't even know there was a wait list! I'm not saying that it will work out for everyone (because it definitely did not for many people in my class), but it's a possibility. I can tell you a lot about my experience as one of the 2 students in the ETP-Anesthesia program for my year. While there are normally 5-10 students, we had an exceptionally small class. I have had both good and bad experiences, and I promise to be honest with you about the Columbia lifestyle and working toward the master's program. Feel free to e-mail me at email@example.com. Even if your specialty is not anesthesia, I can most likely answer your questions about the BSN portion of the program or refer you to a classmate in your preferred specialty. Good luck to you all!