Crossing the Line?

Nurses General Nursing

Published

My first post on this board, and I have a feeling it is sure to attract some heated debate. Here goes...

I've been a nurse for almost 8 yrs and was working most recently at a Level I trauma center in the SICU. Had been working there about 6 months when I started taking care of a 33yo male patient who was injured in a motorcycle accident. He had suffered a T6 complete spinal cord injury and had to be stabilized before he could have extensive surgery to fuse his spine. He was on our unit for approximately 3 weeks, most of the time on the vent w/ heavy paralytics and sedation on board. I was working like mad back then (12 hr noc shifts, tons of overtime) and took care of him most nights I worked. He was barely conscious the majority of the time I cared for him, but the last few days before he was transferred to a stepdown unit (where they almost killed him I might add) he was awake (no head injury, thank God), extubated and being weaned off the sedation. I recognized early on that while the other nurses and the doctors that cared for him gave him the technical care he needed, none of them were supporting him emotionally through such a devastating injury (paralyzed at age 33!). His only family was his dad and he had some friends that inquired about him, though they did not visit in those early stages after his accident. After being transferred to a stepdown unit I began to visit him regularly before and after my shifts and we talked at great length about his accident, injury, recovery etc. I had become a trusted friend and advocate to him and, since he was no longer a patient on the unit where I worked, I was comfortable with that. His recovery was complicated and there were numerous instances when the care he received was less than optimal (bordering malpractice I believe). I tried to bring these issues to the attention of the staff on the other units he was on but was met with a great deal of resistance. Most of the nurses were extremely defensive (especially when they found out I was an evil SICU nurse!). My manager came to me and said she had gotten some complaints from the nurses on the other units he was on, saying that I was "overstepping my bounds." I tried to explain to my manager about the horrible care he was receiving and she brushed me off. Long story short (too late now, huh) I stuck to my guns and advocated for this person (I was told more than once that I'm not a family member, don't get involved, blah, blah, blah). Both the patient and I got into it w/ the other nurses, managers, administrators (I was suspended for 2 days pending an "investigation"...more like an inquisition). He received HORRIBLE care and gross mismanagement almost killed him. To this day he will tell people that if I hadn't intervened on several occasions he would be dead...the senior surgical resident even told me that himself. I've read all the article about "inappropriate therapeutic relationships" with patients but this was nothing like this. A friendship had developed after the time I took care of him on my unit, there was nothing romantic or sexual in nature, and most of all he trusted me to be his advocate during this awful time. I was so disgusted with the management at that institution. I was disgusted with nursing in general at that point. I ended up getting fired some 5 months after that situation, allegedly for calling in sick too many times, though I suspect that had less to do with it than the fact that I had become a squeaky wheel around that place, pointing out the gross malpractice going on. As I told management during my 2 day "inquisition", I would do it all over again and, if needed, I would hire an attorney. Many of those close to me, who knew all the details, suggested I hire an attorney, but to be honest, my main concern was making sure this patient got the kind of care he deserved. Despite being fired form that institution (trust me, they don't "listen better" as their craft advertising slogan goes), I WOULD do it all over again. And if inquiring minds want to know...my friendhip with this patient did develop into a relationship...AFTER he was discharged. I've seen him progress through rehab and getting aclimated to his new world of paraplegia, and having him become a part of my life means more to me than any run-of-the-mill nursing job in the world. Any comments?

WOW, you guys are all so incredible. Thank you so much for all your kind words and support. After stumbling onto this website and posting this story here, I only wish I had known about it back when this was all happening...I really could have used the support, advice and encouragement back then. It has helped me more than you guys could ever know...THANK YOU SO MUCH!

Even with all the frustration and anger I experienced through all this, and especially after reading all of your thoughts and comments, I can honestly say that I don't regret what I did. A job is a job, there are plenty more. And what I gained from this experience is more valuable than any job I've had so far...

I'm slowly letting go of the frustration and bitterness, trying to chalk it all up to a learning experience. I've updated my resume and I think I will do some part-time agency work for awhile...less politics, more money. After this died down and I lost my job, my dad ended up at this hospital (end stage COPD, intubated twice, hospitalized for 3 wks). Then I ended up sick (gallstones) and had a lap chole at the same hospital. Very interesting, being on the other side...but I think it's all made me a much better nurse. I'll surely remember it all the next time I take care of another patient...and the next time I look for a new place to work!;)

Specializes in ICU/ER.

I belive that all that you say could have possibly happened, however I also believe that your objectivity decreased as time passed. We nurses are so eager to blame others for things we think we see or hear, when we weren't there to witness what actually happened...do you hear yourself, "they almost killed him"

that's a horrible statement that should never be made without possesion of all the facts without any hearsay. During you time of reflection it would be wise to look at yourself, your relationship, and your future. I will not put you down, I wasn't there, but I will ask that you take a second look at the entire situation.

mfdteacher, thanks for your input. I have reflected on this, more than you know. And they did almost kill him...or would you be more comfortable if I said they didn't intervene when they should have and so he almost died? Same difference.

Not to be argumentative here, but accusations of almost 'killing someone' is a bit different than implying negligence.. I feel there are enough gross exaggerations in the public perception of healthcare without health care professionals adding fuel to the fire.

Also comments like this could be construed rightfully as libel.

This is a public board...many people read this stuff....

Many here have given you kudos but IMO this is a professional boundary issue that may have repercussions for you. What nurses 'feel' on this board will have no bearing on what YOUR BON will rule if push comes to shove.. I hope nothing comes of it , for your sake, but it could. Hope you've saved documentation should you have to defend your actions.

Good luck to you. :)

Originally posted by mattsmom81

I feel there are enough gross exaggerations in the public perception of healthcare without health care professionals adding fuel to the fire.

And there are enough healthcare professionals covering up or defending poor quality and negligent care...

Specializes in Cardiac/Vascular & Healing Touch.
:cool: :D you are a patient/client advocate! I am so proud of you, & how you care, & how you tried to provide continuity of care. If some one came to me & said "I've been caring for Mr Jones for the last 2 weeks, 2 months, 2 years, whatever....& this is what worked for us...." I'd really take the advice. I mean , they were there first right? Don't reinvent the wheel. Some people are sooooo territorial. I am going through something a little like this now, can't discuss it now, but it pays to be flexible & a patient advocate. Good job!!!!!:kiss

Thanks Suz. I'm glad you could see the importance of advocacy, especially in this situation where he had no one else to advocate for him.

Specializes in Cardiac/Vascular & Healing Touch.
:cool: you got it, we have to support each other. Nurses are so bad about hurting each other, we don't see docs doing this. It must be a female thing? I dunno. Anyhoo, take care of yourself the way you take care of your clients!:chuckle
+ Add a Comment