Legal Issues Legal Issues | allnurses

LEGAL NOTICE TO THE FOLLOWING ALLNURSES SUBSCRIBERS: Pixie.RN, JustBeachyNurse, monkeyhq, duskyjewel, and LadyFree28. An Order has been issued by the United States District Court for the District of Minnesota that affects you in the case EAST COAST TEST PREP LLC v. ALLNURSES.COM, INC. Click here for more information

Legal Issues

  1. 0 Can a patient be detained in any facility without a involuntarily committment certificate or if a patient is a suspected "overdose", is it within our guidelines to attempt to keep someone hospitalized if they do not want to be?
  2. 4 Comments

  3. Visit  ddunnrn profile page
    #1 0
    I don't think Allnurses is meant to be the place for dispensing legal advice, but speaking in general, a court order of some sort is generally required to detain a person for any reason. The implementation varies from state to state. Here in PA, a medical involuntary commitment is very difficult to obtain, and the standard is even more restrictive than the mental health commitments. I once tried to obtain a medical commitment on a severe diabetic with inappropriate behavior who was refusing treatment and wanted to leave, and I was on the phone with a judge 5 hours to get an order just for a finger stick blood sugar test. The rules are there to protect the rights of the individual, but sometimes they can hinder appropriate medical treatment.
  4. Visit  elkpark profile page
    #2 1
    Someone can be detained in a hospital (med-surg) if it is determined by someone qualified/credentialed to do so that the individual does not have the mental capacity at the present time (because of an acute impairment, which might include being s/p an overdose) to make a decision about leaving. Capacity is an issue that has nothing whatsoever to do with, and entirely separate from, involuntary commitment.

    However, an individual's capacity to make a particular healthcare decision is a very flexible, individualized matter, and can change from hour to hour (if not moment to moment). I would think a facility could easily get into some kind of legal trouble if it had a blanket policy that no one with X diagnosis/scenario (like s/p drug overdose) is allowed to choose to leave.
  5. Visit  tinasueb73 profile page
    #3 0
    I appreciate the responses. I simply wondered with the economy and the influx of patients that are often seen with these types of problems, how to protect my license. Patients have a right even though it may not be what we think is best, there is simply that fine line...
  6. Visit  Orca profile page
    #4 1
    Quote from tinasueb73
    Can a patient be detained in any facility without a involuntarily committment certificate or if a patient is a suspected "overdose", is it within our guidelines to attempt to keep someone hospitalized if they do not want to be?
    Generally speaking, a patient must be a clear danger to him/herself or others to be detained, and the doctor must initiate emergency detention order proceedings for this to happen.

    Several years ago I was involved in a situation in which there was a dispute when a patient wanted to leave my mental health unit. The patient called his attorney, who came to visit him. The attorney demanded the immediate release of the patient, which I told him I did not have the authority to do without a physician order. He threatened to have me arrested. In the meantime, the patient's psychiatrist came to the unit for rounds. He got into a heated argument with the lawyer, which I had to ask them to take to a private area to keep from disturbing the other patients. Meanwhile the patient - who was the most calm and rational of all the principals in this - apologized to the staff for what the situation had degenerated into. The house supervisor came by and she was worried about the situation, but I told her to just continue her rounds and I would call her when the dust settled. Finally I called our unit medical director - a more experienced and level-headed individual than the one fighting with the attorney, and a veteran psychiatrist himself. He asked me if I believed the patient qualified for an emergency detention order, and I told him "no". He asked me to bring the other psychiatrist to the phone. They talked it out, and the patient was allowed to leave AMA.

    It was a lot crazier than it needed to be. I never understood the attending psychiatrist's obsession with keeping the patient on the unit regardless of what the patient wanted, because he wasn't dangerous.