Published
Teachers, Police, Firefighters, Military, Government City/State and Nursing. What do they all have in common? Early Retirement Benefits!
Whoopsies...all except for nursing.
Whatsup with THAT....
Anyone?
Talk about being a riot...
You make a comment that, "If the CEO of the hospital is making 2 million/yr they could afford to take much better care of the nurses" and then seek to ridicule me when I point out what fallacious reasoning that is by saying, "why would we eliminate the CEO and divide the pay."
Explain, then, how being able to afford a $2,000,000 annual salary to the CEO also means that "they could afford to take much better care of the nurses?"
You continue to put forth suggestions which are roundly criticized, by both union-friendly nurses such as myself (grateful member of the California Nurses Association) and by those who don't recognize the benefits of collective bargaining. Rather than respond with thoughtful and logical counter arguments, you seek to marginalize and criticize the other posters.
Regardless of the merits of your ideas, your style is earning you no support here and likely none in face-to-face discussions.
If you believe so passionately as you claim, knock yourself out. I will point out, however, that you've not attempted to assess or justify the actual costs and benefits of your fantasy nor have you proposed any transition from the present reality.
Quantify, specify, and justify what you propose and people might take you seriously.
Sounds like you could've used a union to help you with all that...
^If you read my OP thoroughly, I stated that. For my situation, I did what was best that I know how to do-ADVOCATE.
That's exactly what I'm going to do!We turn stress into strength :)
Still want to know how...what is your plan, where
it will benefit ALL nurses without alienating the ones who choose no to or the places that cannot afford the risk? How will you get your local associations on board???
Talk about being a riot...You make a comment that, "If the CEO of the hospital is making 2 million/yr they could afford to take much better care of the nurses" and then seek to ridicule me when I point out what fallacious reasoning that is by saying, "why would we eliminate the CEO and divide the pay."
Explain, then, how being able to afford a $2,000,000 annual salary to the CEO also means that "they could afford to take much better care of the nurses?"
You continue to put forth suggestions which are roundly criticized, by both union-friendly nurses such as myself (grateful member of the California Nurses Association) and by those who don't recognize the benefits of collective bargaining. Rather than respond with thoughtful and logical counter arguments, you seek to marginalize and criticize the other posters.
Regardless of the merits of your ideas, your style is earning you no support here and likely none in face-to-face discussions.
If you believe so passionately as you claim, knock yourself out. I will point out, however, that you've not attempted to assess or justify the actual costs and benefits of your fantasy nor have you proposed any transition from the present reality.
Quantify, specify, and justify what you propose and people might take you seriously.
^This!!!
I am all for protecting and introducing ways to protect nurses, If OP is going to do this, and is proposing this, where is the plan??? Not ideas, operation proposals, cost v risk analysis, things like that...I haven't seen any comments that propose what "stop gap measures" that this proposal will do to strengthen how nurses are treated.
Well said!!!
If I wanted to start a union or a business, why would I document my business plan here for the public to see ESPECIALLY if there is little to no agreement that there is a need. All nurses is a blog for nurses to toss out ideas, feelings, suggestions and so on...in my heart I believe that nurses need unity and protection. This is not about whether you like my personality or not...geeeezz. With the confrontational and argumentative tone of this discussion this does feel like the career 'to die for' This is like killer nurses on steroids...geeeshh... my next thread would specifically require supportive helpful suggestions welcomed...fight nicely.....
Yay! Finally! You were a tough nut to crack....geeeesh...
Not so lol...like I said, I need a fairly based plan that I can see a cause and effect from. I have been an INC and it has made me more of an advocate, as well as I have seen the benefits and what can be improved.
If I am in a well enough situation and have benefited in being able to have the options that I have, I need to see a solution that makes sense to me...If it is something I don't see as a solution, etc, as I saw from your OP, I question it, so I can see it as well. I like things to make sense :)
lkulmann
133 Posts
Agreed...I'm not bitter though freaked-out a little, not bitter. Sounds like you could've used a union to help you with all that...
That's exactly what I'm going to do!
We turn stress into strength :)