Does god make mistakes?

I ran my fingers through his beautiful wavy hair. 3 years old next week! Wow, who would have thought! I looked to his face. Those eyelashes were longer than any I have ever seen. I swear I could feel a breeze when he blinks! Nurses Announcements Archive Article

Updated:  

I looked up at the doctor across the crib who is still hovering over him and checking his ventilator and trachea. Wildly he flailed as the doctor touched his abdomen. I tried to calm him by holding his hand. This is the first I noticed his fingers, some webbed together nearly to the ends, and the digits not coming from the palm in a normal way, but more like a sunburst. I looked more closely at him then. His legs were small and his feet were clubfoot. He has a feeding tube in his distended abdomen. His lips were cracked and crusted and through his open mouth, I could see several jagged sharp teeth coming from his gums at odd angles. Froth poured from his nose. Through his cheeks he had 4 pins on each side that were screwed into his jaw. The doctor was "lengthening" his jaw, it had been broken during surgery and slowly each day, the screws were separated further and further. It looked incredibly painful.

When the doctor had finished the exam, I asked, "Is he receiving physical therapy?" I wondered about his contractures in his legs. The doctor looked at me and sort of laughed. "No! I am trying to convince him mom to sign a DNR order, but she won't! This is his life, this is the best he is ever going to have. This is no life for anyone. He should not have ever gotten this far."

I looked back at the baby. His head is the size of a basketball. His features so close together they would fit in the palm of my hand. His ears line up at his jaw. He blinked and looked right through me, not even seeing me. Maybe the doctor is right, I thought. This would really be a nightmare life to have.

Back in one of my classes, we had a discussion about ethics. I think I wrote something that seemed right to me at the time; honestly, I may have just blown it off and answered what sounded good. I wish I had given it more thought. What right does anyone have to keep this child alive in this state? Why not just disconnect him from the ventilator and let him rest in peace?

Again, I ran my fingers through his hair. I changed his diaper. His bottom was so raw, it was nearly bleeding. He has chronic liquid diarrhea. I applied his barrier ointment liberally. He wears adult diapers. Size small.... This is no life, is it Little One? I looked at him and he seemed to look right into my eyes. "God doesn't make mistakes" someone said. I turned to see who was there. No one. Startled, I returned my gaze to his eyes, and he blinked, his stare gazed through me once again.

Rattled, I weighed his diaper, removed my gloves and gown and washed my hands. I sat down at the desk next to him in ICU where his paperwork is. As I was filling out his charts, his mom came in the room. We talked as she put on her gown and gloves. She climbed on the stool next to his crib and said "Hi Papa!"

I watched as they interacted. I saw the way he responded only to her, to her touch, her voice. They were connected. I saw the look of love in her eyes for him. Her face lit up, her eyes - I am not sure I have ever seen so much love in someone's eyes. I felt mesmerized by the scene, I could not stop staring at them. She talked to him and played with his hair until he fell asleep, and then she came to sit in the chair beside me.

She began to tell me about him, her family. He was the 2nd born child. She had had 8 pregnancies. After he was born, he was immediately flown by helicopter to this hospital, and she did not get to see him for over a week. He has had a lot of surgeries, she said, but he's getting better. He is my gift from God, she said. We all love him so much, his older brother wants their clothes to match so I have to buy them matching clothes, like twins! They love each other so much! He gets so happy when his older brother comes to read him stories and they like to watch cartoons together!

I wondered how much of this was fantasized in her mind - a strange way of coping with his chronic illness, I guess. Denial maybe?

But, it shook my foundation, my thoughts on who gets to "pull the plug". Who has the "right to be God"...50 years ago, he would have been dead and buried. Now, through technology, he is kept alive. Who is right? Who is wrong?

We, as nursing students, are encouraged to Know What We Believe. That way, down the road, we won't be shaken to our core when faced with situations such as this. I thought I knew what I believed. Now it is in my face. A mother looking down with kindness, compassion, care, love, gentleness and hope on her child who only seems to see her and respond to her touch and her voice.

A child that seems genuinely thrilled when she is near.

I now understood just why the mother could not sign the papers. She knew it better than anyone. God does not make mistakes.

Specializes in psychiatric, UR analyst, fraud, DME,MedB.
nurseatrest1963 said:
This story was told very well, even showing your change of heart took courage...Not everyone is capable of taking good care of special needs children...it is often totally heart breaking...whether the child was born this way or something traumatic caused the disease state. Often a mother or fathers heart is the only real connection that you can "actually see", like a window to the childs heart/soul...Have you ever worked with a closed head injured pt...and wondered whether there was anyone in there, and months later they actually woke up!? Its amazing, and totally unexpected, yet it does happen...Medicine is amazing, its Gods gift, and His grace, His hope applied to our lives ...but...we are only PRACTICING medicine, as nurses etc...We are His healing hands, His touch, His hug, that can be passed on from person to person...Over the yrs (or even only months)...how many miracles have you taken place in....have you assisted in a birth? WOW!! Have you held someones hand, or just sat with someone through the dying process...It is just really hard for me to believe that some big bang happened and all the cells lined up and poof, a human was created ...over time...yeah right...everything is essentially made out of the same ole stuff, and yet, one is a human, another a dog, and another a plant...hmm I just can't wrap my mind around that...My answer, my hearts belief is that there is a God..whatever you call your creator...its all about faith..we get too smart for our britches (I know, kind of hick sounding--but you get my drift), and all of a sudden we question our very existence...I honestly don't know where all this came from....I had a grandchild who lived a little less than an hour...the Dr...(the so called specialist) wanted my grand daughter to be born lady partslly, so that it woud quicken her death...was suppose to be "MORE HUMANE" The actual birth would probably cause her to be stillborn..During a "cheating" ultrasound to find out whether my grandbaby was a boy or girl (small town hospital---friend did an ultrasound)...the Small town Dr. was called in on a sunday Dr. M came into the hospital off of the tractor in his cowboy boots/jeans..and helped us understand what the ultrasound tech saw...My grand daughter had an omphalocele...and would need a specialized ultrasound, and specialist to determine what our next moves should be...He was kind and gave us hope...Until the specialist informed us that "IT WAS NOT VIABLE"...My daughter knew that didn't sound good, and I became well...Ticked off immediately...I let the Dr. know he needed to explain to my daughter what he meant, and that he better find his compasionate side while doing so!! Anyway, my grand daughter had Pentology of Cantrel...and a multitude of abnormalties. The Dr told us she had 3 days to decide to abort it!....My daughter told him right then and there that her baby girls life was in Gods hands, and chose to carry her...surpisingly Justina went to almost full term...was born 4pounds 13oz, blonde hair, ....(sorry I am jumping around)...when my daughter went into labor the Dr/Specialist said she needed to deliver lady partslly it was best for the baby! Yeah, RIGHT...we knew she was malformed, with severe scoliosis, etc (sort of fused bent like a L shape,) her intestines were on the outside, as well as her heart, she only had a partial diaphragm, her lungs were incomplete...and they said a lady partsl birth would be best (so that she would suffer less!!)...They were making my daughter labor, on top of everything else, I thought this was so unfair...labor is suppose to have a wonderful outcome...why go through it when there is so little chance...and why tear a baby apart while traveling through the birth canal!!! What's fair about that..to die in birth...not to mention that my daughter was still young, and wanted more than anything in life to be a "mother"..and what the Dr. proposed posed a serious danger to my daughter..and her chances of having children again...He suggested that a C-section was a high risk too...(He didn't know I was a surgical nurse, who assisted in C-sections)Anyway, I went over his head...my daughter had a c-section and my grand daughter was born! She lived less than an hour...I held her, and literally watched her little heart beat, and her lungs take their breaths...she gave it her best shot...but grandma sung to her, and held her, until Jesus took her in His loving arms...My daughter had a chance to meet her daughter, and to say goodbye. This was yrs ago..could she have lived today with intervention? Maybe..but Gods grace was sufficient...Is this all why now yrs later I have changed directions once again and find myself working with special needs children...I enjoy seeing the smiles/and facial expressions these children have...the light that shines in their eyes when they recognize their family, and yes, even their nurse! I know someone is in there...how much they understand, how far they will go in life...isn't up to me. I can't control any of that, but I can control portions of their health. I can give them good care, with Love and tenderness, laughter and joy...isn't that what we all need....(by the way--if you are taking care of a child, and they are not being cared for properly, is CPS involved? Or is it a situation where alls you can do is your best, whether it be in their home, or institution they all deserve our best...if you can't give loving care then maybe its time for a change. God Bless all those that give their best for these truly special children (and adults)!

Thank you for a wonderful and tear jerking story---------yes, that baby is in Gods loving hands now. Sometimes our experience along the way in life will show us as to where we would like to spend our nursing skills....more than once so go where your heart tugs you....chances are this is where you are needed for a certain time...

Great story really thx ;)

Specializes in variety of hospital areas, including OR.

By the way...I forgot one major issue...they wanted to have a lady partsl birth...cost effective for a person with no insurance!, vs C-section....I hope these kind of choices don't become the norm due to government involvement in our health care system...It really is yet to be seen, as for right now, I think we hear what the govt wants us to hear...

Specializes in psychiatric, UR analyst, fraud, DME,MedB.
nurseatrest1963 said:
By the way...I forgot one major issue...they wanted to have a lady partsl birth...cost effective for a person with no insurance!, vs C-section....I hope these kind of choices don't become the norm due to government involvement in our health care system...It really is yet to be seen, as for right now, I think we hear what the govt wants us to hear...

:nurse: I hope not. I know the government credibility is pretty yuccky right now considering all the things that they let happen, such as the AIG, Enron, Big automobile corporate------ nobody was watching really, no regulation in place for these corporates,( they have strong lobbyist that pushed their greedy interests) so they got away w/ bloody murder---- and the middle class is in burden w/ the tax alone, since the rich have loopholes not to pay or the minimum , and the poor ones have no money to pay.......so we are the worker ants, or the mule ---the ones that works so hard and carries heavy burdens on their back, right?

But not to try to change the healthcare right now will be a big mistake and a horrendous chaos since healthcare expenses will bankrupt the nation---- and lots of people and children will not get any care 'cause it will be too expensive.Cost effective is reasonable, but in your case w/ the baby ----there are ethics involve . No way you can allow a lady partsl birth because it is cheaper. The baby is entitled to a comfortable and as pain free as possible birth. The t cells are protected, why not a full and breathing baby ??? You know what I mean?

If ever comes a time wherein cost is first before ethics , then we are damned and God help us!!!!

Thank you for sharing!

Specializes in Wilderness Medicine, ICU, Adult Ed..

Cardiacnurse2006, I am sorry this is so painful for you. I have lost a child, so I am not being condescending when I tell you that I understand both your pain and your anger, and I am not criticizing you for either. Yes, as I think the OP was illustrating in her excellent story, good and bad do exist, and much that happens in the world is terribly bad. And trying to decide who to blame is tempting, but futile. I do not know why the child in the OP's story was born so tragically impaired, nor do I know why (or blame anyone) for your tragedy, or for the loss of my own child. My only point was, that all that is bad in the world does not change the fact that life still has value, and there is still good in this evil world.

Specializes in LTC, CPR instructor, First aid instructor..
CountyRat said:
Cardiacnurse2006, I am sorry this is so painful for you. I have lost a child, so I am not being condescending when I tell you that I understand both your pain and your anger, and I am not criticizing you for either. Yes, as I think the OP was illustrating in her excellent story, good and bad do exist, and much that happens in the world is terribly bad. And trying to decide who to blame is tempting, but futile. I do not know why the child in the OP's story was born so tragically impaired, nor do I know why (or blame anyone) for your tragedy, or for the loss of my own child. My only point was, that all that is bad in the world does not change the fact that life still has value, and there is still good in this evil world.

Wonderful, and very gentle reply.

Specializes in LTC, CPR instructor, First aid instructor..

Cardiacnurse2006,

I'm sorry you are in so much pain. None of us really knows why we are either unable to conceive, but over the several years of my life I have seen an increase in infertility. I lost a baby in my first trimester, and it felt like my baby had died. It took a long while before I could come to terms with that loss and accept it. When I lost my baby, I held it's tiny body all curled up in the fetal position, studying its features; its puffy tiny cheeks, studying to see if it had 10 fingers and toes, its tiny nose, and the perfect circles where its eyes were yet to form. Then after a while sitting on the bathroom toilet where I gave it birth, my baby who had features a lot like my oldest daughter, melted before my eyes.

Do we know why these things happen? I don't think so. All I know is that I can still see that tiny baby in my mind's eye. Perhaps one of the causes to infertility is caused by the artificial food additives that are put into our food?

You have my deepest condolences.

This story was so touching. My brother was born with cerebral palsy. He went through 30+ surgeries in his lifetime, and I'm sure you could draw the conclusion of how many doctor visits and hospital stays that means. He passed away last October at the age of 31, a long time for someone to live with the severe case of CP that he had. The last two months of his life he spent in and out of the hospital, and I asked the same question about God making mistakes so many times. After he died I really go bitter and kept on asking. But I couldn't imagine my life without him. He was my mom's whole world, and he responded to her better than anyone else just like the boy in the story. I was never settled with the thought of him suffering so long because I thought we were being selfish. But I also know it would be so hard to have let him go any sooner. It's a hard situation, and you have to understand that before you judge other people and the decisions they make about their kid's/families lives. As a nurse, you can care about the child, but making those kind of decision is NOT your place.

Stephanie

Specializes in School Nurse, Maternal Newborn.
nurseatrest1963 said:
By the way...I forgot one major issue...they wanted to have a lady partsl birth...cost effective for a person with no insurance!, vs C-section....I hope these kind of choices don't become the norm due to government involvement in our health care system...It really is yet to be seen, as for right now, I think we hear what the govt wants us to hear...

Not to take anything away from your experience, but as a very long time OB nurse- several reasons that babies that are not expected to survive are delivered lady partslly, and NOT just because of money- every incision into the uterus has implications for the mothers future fertility. Also, a lady partsl birth does allow the mother the ability to gather her belongings after the delivery,go home to her loved ones, and prepare for the funeral of her much wanted baby. If she has a c-section, often she will continue to be cared for on a unit that has mothers with live babies.:cry: Just my experience.

Specializes in variety of hospital areas, including OR.

Artistyc1, you are right on all accts...But in this situation the Dr, actually stated the stress of the delivery would cause the birth of the baby be a still birth...and that it would be traumatic on the baby, and the lady partsl canal...He expected problems... and even comented that this situation could cause problems for my daughter in the future...anyway...and I made sure that my daughter went to surgical floor, not OB with new babies on the floor....I have experienced this first hand as a nurse before (where the baby didn't survive, and they were placed on a floor with crying newborns...very traumatic for the mother/family)...Thanks for your coments...

Specializes in psychiatric, UR analyst, fraud, DME,MedB.
nurseatrest1963 said:
Artistyc1, you are right on all accts...But in this situation the Dr, actually stated the stress of the delivery would cause the birth of the baby be a still birth...and that it would be traumatic on the baby, and the lady partsl canal...He expected problems... and even comented that this situation could cause problems for my daughter in the future...anyway...and I made sure that my daughter went to surgical floor, not OB with new babies on the floor....I have experienced this first hand as a nurse before (where the baby didn't survive, and they were placed on a floor with crying newborns...very traumatic for the mother/family)...Thanks for your coments...

I am really surprised that the OB floor does not have a policy or procedure to follow as to where to put the mother and the dead baby......... considering the trauma the mother and the family are going through and hearing all those live crying babies is just too mcuh to bear-- it is like rubbing salt on an open wound!! I hope they will find a place --away from the OB for mothers who have still births. Anyone worked in a hospital w/ a much compassion and understanding policy for mom w/ still births?