Mandatory Flu Shot

Nurses COVID

Published

  1. Should Healthcare Professionals Be Required To Take Flu Shot?

    • 14
      Yes
    • 12
      No
    • 0
      Unsure

26 members have participated

I have to say that I am completely outraged by the push for mandated flu shots. What happened to personal freedom, especially to make our own healthcare decisions? And please spare me the "it's about the patient's" **** ****. First of all, the vaccine is up to 60% effective on a good day and is supposed to create antibodies to 3 strains of the virus. Problem is, there is hundreds of them out there. Not only that, but the chances of you actually getting the flu is small. Think about how many people got the flu shot and still got sick. Works Great! Let me also make it clear, I am not "anti-vaccine" because I do feel they have a place in our society. The mandatory ones we get as children actually have a much higher success (i.e. MMR 95% +) and we only have to get a series of them ONCE! It is simply outrageous that we are mandated to get this shot EVERY year. Forced to inject myself with countless chemicals, every year for a false sense of security? People need to step out the herd and really educate themselves. Did you know that hospitals that require all employees to have flu shots have an incentive to do so? Try following the money.... The bottom line is, we are hired as healthcare professionals to educate, and execute healthcare on patients, but we can't make our own healthcare decisions? If a patient is admitted into the hospital he should be educated on the risks of the flu, and the risks/benefits of a flu shot. The patients are the ones who should be offered the vaccine upon admittance. Both of us being vaccinated against the same exact thing is over-kill. After all we are trying to protect the patients, right? Before you head the line of yearly injection, why don't you think about the effects it might have on your body 20+ years from now. Your guess is as a good as anyones......

That is initial estimates based on facts which are consistent with 50-80+% historical findings. I think most logical people if told they had a 50-80% chance of not getting the flu and even greater chance of having reduced symptoms if you do get the flu by getting the flu shot would get the flu shot.

The last sentence does not make sense to me. Are you saying should someone enter a room without PPE if the patient has confirmed influenza or is on airborne precautions? Then the answer would be no and the answer would be the same if they had the chickenpox, HiB, measles, TB, etc.

No, I'm asking you should standard precaution be to wear a mask at all time during flu season? HCW getting the flu shot is about protecting the patient, right? So, if a patient is on airborne precautions, obviously we wouldn't enter without proper PPE.

Jordan1230 What is your educational/work background, because it seems your only purpose on this board has been to try refute the importance of flu vaccines?

My only purpose on this board isn't to refute to the importance of flu vaccines, it's also to refute the mandate of it.

Education: AS Life Science, BS Psychology, ABSN (in progress)

Work: Home Care, Neuro Floor, Primary Care

Specializes in Anesthesia.
No, I'm asking you should standard precaution be to wear a mask at all time during flu season? HCW getting the flu shot is about protecting the patient, right? So, if a patient is on airborne precautions, obviously we wouldn't enter without proper PPE.

A surgical mask is to protect the patient from you and is only minimally effective if worn correctly. It is a poor replacement for the flu vaccine and there is not a reason for an other wise healthy HCW to wear a surgical mask if they have gotten the flu vaccine unless it is part of their PPE &/or sterile attire when dealing with droplet precautions or doing sterile procedures.

Specializes in Anesthesia.
My only purpose on this board isn't to refute to the importance of flu vaccines, it's also to refute the mandate of it.

Education: AS Life Science, BS Psychology, ABSN (in progress)

Work: Home Care, Neuro Floor, Primary Care

Good for you that sounds like a great start to a nursing career. I think psychology will be a great asset in all aspects of nursing, teaching, and/or administration that you will chose in the future.

I still don't see how these degrees give you special insight to refute expert opinions on recommending flu vaccines.

I don't claim to be an expert in epidemiology, but my background does train me to proficient in the use of EBP.

My education just to be fair: AA, LVN, BSN, MSN/CRNA, DNAP (Doctorate of Nurse Anesthesia Practice with a focus on Nurse anesthesia Education), and I will start my PhD in Nursing hopefully this fall with a planned research focus on the effects of volatile anesthetics in the brain on mice with induced PTSD.

Thank you, but I don't think that my degrees give me any special insight. I only mention it because I was asked.

Congratulations on all that you have accomplished. And best of luck this fall.

Specializes in Anesthesia.
Thank you, but I don't think that my degrees give me any special insight. I only mention it because I was asked.

Congratulations on all that you have accomplished. And best of luck this fall.

I actually disagree. We are taught in anesthesia that one of top reasons patients choose not to sue is based on your rapport with them. I think your degree in psychology will serve you well!

+ Add a Comment