Nursing Research: Comparative vs Descriptive Design Nursing Research: Comparative vs Descriptive Design | allnurses

LEGAL NOTICE TO THE FOLLOWING ALLNURSES SUBSCRIBERS: Pixie.RN, JustBeachyNurse, monkeyhq, duskyjewel, and LadyFree28. An Order has been issued by the United States District Court for the District of Minnesota that affects you in the case EAST COAST TEST PREP LLC v. ALLNURSES.COM, INC. Click here for more information

Nursing Research: Comparative vs Descriptive Design

  1. 0 I am currently taking an Intro to Nursing Research class. We were given an article and had to determine whether the article is a Comparative Descriptive Design article or (typical) Descriptive Design article. I have figured out most of the questions needed to determine the design type; but I am stuck on one last question!

    Is the article researching ONE GROUP or MULTIPLE GROUPS?

    The following is an excerpt from the article entitled: "Comparison of Oral and Tympanic Temperatures in Adult Surgical Patients"

    "Design and Sample
    A repeated-measures design was used to determine the reproducibility of tympanic and oral temperature measurements. The study was conducted on three surgical units at a tertiary-care center.
    Temperatures (oral and tympanic) were obtained on a sample of 257 adult surgical patients based on the standard vital sign times of the units involved."

    Thanks for your time!
    Gilbert, M., Barton, A., & Counsell, C. (2002). Comparison of tympanic and oral temperatures in surgical patients. Applied Nursing Research, 15(1), 2002. Retrieved from CINAHL Plus with Full Text database.

  2. 2 Comments

  3. Visit  llg profile page
    #1 0
    So ... it was 1 group of patients and each patient had their temperature taken 2 ways?
  4. Visit  RNTutor profile page
    #2 0
    Sounds like 1 group to me. The other clue is "repeated measures" design. A repeated measures design will take the same person and change a variable for that particular person (in this case, how the temp was taken). So the data is being compared "within" each person, so to speak.

    If it was a multiple group study, then you would have had one group of people have their temp taken orally, and a different group of people have their temp taken tympanically