Did You Know?
allnurses is the largest community for nurses on the web. We now have over 388,788 members! Join today to network with other nurses, laugh, share, and much more.
| No. 40 |
Jun 06, 2009, 11:57 PM
Re: Unions. What do they do for us? Originally Posted by momatwork Hi herring RN,
I appreciate your response..........but my hospital has those things without a union.........we have a nurse policy/practice council, and good staffing ratios. They are posted daily in my state, and ours are better than the union hospitals......Our salaries and benefits are excellant as well. Its not necessary to pay a for profit entity 1% of my gross salary plus 4.00 a pay to speak for me.
First, unions are emphatically not "for-profit". All the ones I know of are incorporated as non-profit entities under Sec 501c - the section of federal law that governs non-profit entities incorporated for mutual benefit of the members or the public good. Our executive director running the operations of the largest and most effective union in the country makes a salary about a third of that of the CEO of the small town hospital I work at, so rather under paid from my standpoint. When I meet nurses from other states, I am hearing horror stories of nurses being laid off, salaries and benefits cut and work loads increasing. Things we don't see in California because of the strength of our union here. I also hear of nurses being blacklisted, and even now in Texas, a largely non-union state, the employers have formed an organization for the specific purpose of blacklisting nurses. Again, things we don't have to worry about here.
And I've seen plenty of those shared governance type councils - run by management with no power and no effect other than giving nurses the illusion they are being listened to. I'll take our PPC any day.
| | Advertisement Sponsored Links | | | | No. 41 |
Jun 07, 2009, 12:05 AM
Updated
Jun 07, 2009 at 11:21 AM by herring_RN
Re: Unions. What do they do for us? Originally Posted by momatwork Hi herring RN,
I appreciate your response..........but my hospital has those things without a union.........we have a nurse policy/practice council, and good staffing ratios. They are posted daily in my state, and ours are better than the union hospitals......Our salaries and benefits are excellant as well. Its not necessary to pay a for profit entity 1% of my gross salary plus 4.00 a pay to speak for me.
It seems as though you have an excellent situation.
Nurses don't call a union when they can provide the kind of care we were taught to in school. When we can say, "This patient needs a sitter." and get someone.
Or, "I'm not competent to float to NICU." and a competent NICU RN is found, or,
"We need another CNA because our patients are physiacally heavy." and get the requested help, or
are able to truly take 1/2 hour for lunch because a competent RN takes report and responsibility for our patients, or "The acuity is high. We need another nurse." and get another nurse, or to
broken suction cannisters, O2 flowmeters, or siderails and have them immediately repaired or replaced.
At my hospital patient care was suffering with new management so WE called several unions and chose our state nurses association.
Now all the above exists at our hospital.
The union didn't do it for us. WE did it with the help of OUR union. (Not a for profit corporation)
I'm not trying to convince anyone. Just to explain a little about how WE improve patient care and our working lives. http://www.calnurses.org/assets/pdf/nnoc_101.pdf | | No. 42 |
Jun 09, 2009, 02:58 AM
Re: Unions. What do they do for us? Anyone else see these hospitals' and employers' behaviors and the nurses' responses as being similar, as though we were discussing domestic abuse? Or victims of hostile/involuntary captivity (Stockholm) syndrome?...where nurses begin to identify with and support their boss's policies and their oppressive working conditions?
OMG! ALL THE TIME !!!!! !!
When we look over at history, during the civil rights movement when people were trying to establish their rights, there was also a nationalist movement within the segregated groups that felt that integration was selling out. They wanted to be segregated and "self-sufficient".
It's seems almost unreal to imagine if African -Americans, Chicanos, American -Indians and women never got the right to vote, to have a say in their government, to have access to the rights that all other classes enjoined.
Those rights were not gain easily and not by standing up for themselves alone. The greatest thing that happened was that people stuck together and won those rights TOGETHER!
Nurses need to be united. A great nurse I work with says it all the time " we are not at war with management... but we are in conflict" (G. Pickett) and it's true! Anyone who believes that hospitals are not businesses is delusional. Administration MUST watch the budget. Nurses MUST care for the patients. Unions help us as a means to come together and have a dialog in a formal and professional matter. It's a way for us to win rights. Rights for advocacy, rights for professional wages, and rights to push our profession forward.
I know this board will never change the minds of those who believe it is wrong to stand together. But I will never give up on our profession, we are gaining our rights united in unions! | | No. 43 |
Jun 09, 2009, 03:39 AM
Re: Unions. What do they do for us?
My union in my hospital ( I live just outside of Settle) takes my raise. Every time I get a raise, my union dues go up.
| | No. 44 |
Jun 09, 2009, 11:13 AM
Re: Unions. What do they do for us? Originally Posted by diane227 My union in my hospital ( I live just outside of Settle) takes my raise. Every time I get a raise, my union dues go up.
You must belong to WSNA. They are here in Spokane, and all over Washington State. Trust me, the nurses here have gotten NOTHING from them! We need to get the NNOC and the CNA here in Washington, to obtain more power to the nurses of Washington State. JMHO and my NY $0.02.
Lindarn, RN, BSN, CCRN
Spokane, Washington
| | No. 45 |
Jun 12, 2009, 01:20 PM
Re: Unions. What do they do for us?
Hello All,
When I said a for profit entity, by that I meant that it does profit from the dues of its members. The unions in my state belong to AFT, and the larger union AFL. All anyone needs to do is take at look at their profits, which are posted on the internet. Look at their contributions to lobbyists as well. They do not ask their members which organizations to support. The Presidents, VPs and other administrators of the union do profit by this organization as well. Their salaries are 6 figures, and that does not count the perks of hotels, lodging, and expense reports. In addition, they are salaried by the larger unions in various positions. The union is not there out of the kindness of their hearts, they like a hospital or any organization, are there to make money. When a hospital in my state was closed, the union sought to take dues out of severance pays...........without a contract, there are no dues, so a union does seek a contract ratified, and at times is self-serving in that goal. Perhaps your unions have a better track record. The best thing I can tell anyone is to become informed. If your hospital has not reached the point of a major communications breakdown between staff and management, then approach them as a group and speak for yourselves. Why pay someone a substancial amount of money to do this? As nurses, we are a highly educated group of professionals, use that education to communicate for yourselves.
| | No. 46 |
Jun 28, 2009, 02:48 PM
Re: Unions. What do they do for us? When Teresa Barnett, a nurse at Menorah Medical Center in Kansas City, Mo.,
began to organize a union at her hospital, she said, “We didn’t even want to use the
word ‘union’ because many of us thought it had a bad connotation.” But, Barnett,
continued, “we really believed we could make a difference by having a legal voice in
the workplace, and unionizing was the way to do that” (Heaster 2001).
With collective bargaining agreements with individual hospitals and chains of
health care facilities, nurses are improving patient care as well as their own economic
conditions. For instance, an agreement worked out in 2002 between CNA and Kaiser
Permanente, covering 10,200 registered nurses and nurse practitioners throughout
California – the largest single contract for nurses in the nation – includes a ban on
mandatory overtime, a guaranteed pension three times larger than the previous plan,
a retirement health plan, and a no-cancellation program covering regularly assigned
shifts, the first of its kind in the industry. The language on mandatory overtime was the
strongest in the country, and the union hopes it will set a national standard (Business
Wire 2002). http://epi.3cdn.net/1f9884ef0ee804bfaa_70m6b39ft.pdf | | No. 47 |
Jun 29, 2009, 06:34 AM
Re: Unions. What do they do for us? Originally Posted by momatwork Hello All,
When I said a for profit entity, by that I meant that it does profit from the dues of its members. The unions in my state belong to AFT, and the larger union AFL. All anyone needs to do is take at look at their profits, which are posted on the internet. Look at their contributions to lobbyists as well. They do not ask their members which organizations to support. The Presidents, VPs and other administrators of the union do profit by this organization as well. Their salaries are 6 figures, and that does not count the perks of hotels, lodging, and expense reports. In addition, they are salaried by the larger unions in various positions. The union is not there out of the kindness of their hearts, they like a hospital or any organization, are there to make money. When a hospital in my state was closed, the union sought to take dues out of severance pays...........without a contract, there are no dues, so a union does seek a contract ratified, and at times is self-serving in that goal. Perhaps your unions have a better track record. The best thing I can tell anyone is to become informed. If your hospital has not reached the point of a major communications breakdown between staff and management, then approach them as a group and speak for yourselves. Why pay someone a substancial amount of money to do this? As nurses, we are a highly educated group of professionals, use that education to communicate for yourselves.
Excuse me, but as professional employees who have a fiduciary duty to advocate in the exclusive interests of the patients we care for, we should organize into RN unions, like NNOC/CNA and approach management with one collective voice. I think it's an intelligent and reasonable course of action. Hospital executives work under contract and hospitals belong to industry trade unions, so why is it o.k. in your book, for them to be collectively organized and pay a "substantial amount of money" for business administration, contracts, and representation and not nurses?
Union members speak with us, not "for" us. We democratically elect our board of directors, reps, negotiatiors, and professional practice committees. Our dues are paid for our collective benefit in support of our mission, vision, and philosophy; not for the individual "profit" of any one member! We maintain a professional support staff of organizers, labor representatives, contract negotiators and administrative support staff, printed materials, and labor attorneys, accountants, and government/legislative advocacy staff. We have succeeded in sponsoring legislation to protect patients like safe RN to patient ratio laws and whistle-blower protection for nurses who speak out about the unsafe business practices of their employers.
So, fair is fair; a union contract is the great equalizer between employees and management. Registered Nurses have unique accountabilities and responsibility for the provision of patient care. No one has the right to interfere with that duty but let's be honest here, hospital administrators often try and succeed in imposing barriers to our ability to provide safe, effective, and competent care.
I guess my question would be why would AFT, a teachers' union, be trying to represent nurses? I believe it's important that nurses join and have representation by nurses in an all RN union. | | No. 48 |
Jul 01, 2009, 03:05 PM
Updated
Jul 01, 2009 at 03:27 PM by laborer
| | 235 members
1,931 guests 2,166 | 46 | | | 1 | | | 13 | | | 2 | | | 10 | | | 17 | | | 11 | | | 16 | | | 16 | | | 42 | | | 14 | | | 21 | | | 23 | | | 20 | | | 24 | | |
Nursing News