question about HIPAA

\ said:

I am a nursing student and I recently had a professor say that pt stories (even without identifiable characteristics) that she tells us in class is confidential and would be a HIPAA violation if we repeated them outside of class because they were real patients. I thought I was fairly clear of what HIPAA said about privacy until she said that. Anyone care to elaborate?

It is my understanding the as long as the "story" doesn't include identifying information such as name, date of birth, SSN, hospital name, dates of stay, etc (anything that could link the story to that particular individual) then it would be considered de-identified and therefore not a HIPAA violation.

She is wrong. She is trying to put the fear of god in you about patient confidentiality, which is fine, but she is wrong. It is disheartening to me to hear faculty telling students inaccurate boogey-man stories about HIPAA because when their students discover they're wrong they lose face and credibility in other ways. And the students may get the wrong idea about HIPAA and violate it later.

There are some iffy areas. Suppose I talk about a child who sustained a head injury and was now vented. If we were in my small hometown, everyone would know who I was talking about. If I were in New York City, it's more likely nobody would be able to identify the patient just based on the diagnosis.

In either case it's wise not to tell patient tales outside of the health care arena or without a good reason such as teaching. Doing so makes us look like gossips and shines poorly on the profession. I had a friend of my wife who requested me as her nurse because she trusted that I would keep her care confidential. Her trust was well founded and that's all I'll say about that.

I am a nursing student, and I recently had a professor say that pt stories (even without identifiable characteristics) that she tells us in class is confidential and would be a HIPAA violation if we repeated them outside of class because they were real patients.

At my nursing school, we had an instructor tell us that. That was her given rationale for why she would not allow students to tape her lectures. According to her, if we let someone else hear the tape, then it would be a violation. "It's HIPAA plain and simple," she said. On a side note, I just think she didn't want students to tape her lectures because the were really bad and she did want her "bad" lectures getting around...she was really good as a clinical instructor though.

Here's the thing. If your repeating the stories would be a HIPAA violation, then she would be 'committing' a HIPAA violation by telling you the story in the first place.

Just make sure that you don't go out in public and yell your story when you're sitting at the bar...if you want to tell a story, I'd wait til you're in private.

At my nursing school, we had an instructor tell us that. That was her given rationale for why she would not allow students to tape her lectures. According to her, if we let someone else hear the tape, then it would be a violation. "It's HIPAA plain and simple," she said. On a side note, I just think she didn't want students to tape her lectures because the were really bad and she did want her "bad" lectures getting around...she was really good as a clinical instructor though.

Here's the thing. If your repeating the stories would be a HIPAA violation, then she would be 'committing' a HIPAA violation by telling you the story in the first place.

Education of health care professionals is an exception under HIPAA. She can tell all the stories she wants, give real-life examples, and it is not a violation, as long as she does it in a classroom, clinical setting.

That is why she said it was ok for her to tell you (the students) but it's not ok for you to repeat the same stories or other things at work.

psu_213 said:

At my nursing school, we had an instructor tell us that. That was her given rationale for why she would not allow students to tape her lectures. According to her, if we let someone else hear the tape, then it would be a violation. "It's HIPAA plain and simple," she said. On a side note, I just think she didn't want students to tape her lectures because the were really bad and she did want her "bad" lectures getting around...she was really good as a clinical instructor though.

Here's the thing. If your repeating the stories would be a HIPAA violation, then she would be 'committing' a HIPAA violation by telling you the story in the first place.

Not necessarily. Information may be shared in an educational context with as little private identifying information as possible. However, what's appropriate to share in an educational context may not be appropriate to share outside of the classroom/clinical conference/M&M conference, etc.

There are some iffy areas. Suppose I talk about a child who sustained a head injury and was now vented. If we were in my small hometown, everyone would know who I was talking about. If I were in New York City, it's more likely nobody would be able to identify the patient just based on the diagnosis.

In either case it's wise not to tell patient tales outside of the health care arena or without a good reason such as teaching. Doing so makes us look like gossips and shines poorly on the profession. I had a friend of my wife who requested me as her nurse because she trusted that I would keep her care confidential. Her trust was well founded and that's all I'll say about that.

Absolutely! Thanks for the post.

HIPPA is as complex and weird as Obamacare, but every place has to have a HIPPA compliance officer that sets, and follows the rules of the new laws. So I'd advise following the policy of your work, school, or whatever, to not be so scared of it all?

HIPPA is as complex and weird as Obamacare, but every place has to have a HIPPA compliance officer that sets, and follows the rules of the new laws. So I'd advise following the policy of your work, school, or whatever, to not be so scared of it all?

HIPAA (please watch your spelling) is not complex and not weird. The only thing that's confusing and weird to me is why people don't bother to remember what they learned in the inservice/walk across the nurses' station to read the FAQs/look at the sticky thread at the bottom to see what is and what is not PHI. https://allnurses.com/hipaa-nursing-challenges/answer-hipaa-violation-693686.html

It's not rocket science and not scary.