Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

allnurses

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Discussion

Question about an accident

I wanted to share something with you guys because i know you may can help me understand.

I was driving home from work one day when i witnessed a car accident. It was raining very hard and the roads were extremely slick. The car in front of me slide off the road and hit a tree on the passenger side. I slammed on breaks and ran to the scene. When i went to the car the people inside were already dead. I looked inside (which was not a good thing) and saw the passenger lying up against the window, missing half of her head. The driver was also dead, lying over in the passengers lap. This was the most horrifying thing i had ever seen. I was in total panic. I called 911 immediatley and sat there until they arrived. While i was there i just couldnt keep my eyes off them and i noticed that the passenger was somehow breathing. her lips were moving and her chest was moving up and down. Please explain this to me? Was she dead or did she have any chance at life? The police didnt arrive until an HOUR after i called them. ( I checked the time i had called the police on my cell phone). When they got there they didnt even check the pulse or anything. they threw a blue sheet over the car and waited on the paramedics to arrive (which felt like about 10 min after the police got there). I just didnt understand why no one would check to see if she could have made it or not. I asked the EMT why her chest was moving up and down like she was trying to breath and he said there would have been no chance for survival and that the body just does that (kindof like a reflex) is this true? I just cant get over what happend and i cant really describe in words how i felt. I feel as though i took things fairly well being ive never seen anything like it before. I was really scared and shocked. Just thought some of you could explain to me what i saw. Was she dead or was she dying right there in front of me? could there have been hope for her at all?

Featured Replies

First of all, I'm glad you weren't hurt in this accident. It's so terrifying to see a car so close to you go out of control, wondering if they might hit you. The shock of "Oh my God, that could have been me" if horrible. I agree that you should seek professional help. You might want to call the EMS station or police to see who they recommend. After a traumatic incident, personnel usually have what is called a critical incident stress debriefing, where people involved in the incident have the chance to talk about what happened, with professionals.

I also agree with the brainstem activity. It seems unreal to me the response time it took, but I've never lived in an area that was that far away from a responder. With EMS, some areas have direct protocols for no-codes (where not life saving action is performed). This includes if rigor mortis is set in, or decapitation.

You did the right thing by staying on the scene until help arrived and for even bothering to stop. Good for you, and just realize what happened to them was out of your control. -Andrea

What a tragic accident! And how good of you to stop and to wait for the ambulance to get there; many people would not even have taken the time to do that.

As you can see by my name, I'm a nurse who works in a hospital. I've never seen anything like what you describe. I'm certain that if I did, I would be very shaken up, and I would need to talk to someone about it.

I am posting because I have also seen dying people have that kind of breathing and sometimes other movement that is caused by brainstem activity, for a long period of time after they have died. Further, I also don't believe the person you describe was actually alive, but that there was only the brainstem activity causing the movements you describe.

Come back and talk all you need to, but I hope you will find some professional to talk to about this traumatic event that happened to you. A professional nurse could not have done any more than you did, and I commend you for your caring actions.

:icon_hug:

I agree that attending a CISD (critical incident stress debriefing) would be helpful for you in this situtation. I attended one after running a particularly bad MVA (2 fatalities, 1 critical w/ prolonged extrication) and I found it very helpful. You can also check with the departments that ran this call (law enforcement, FD and/or EMS) and see if you can talk to a Victim's Assistance counselor. These would be available for no fee.

I also wanted to add a comment on the response time - the OP stated that this accident happened during a heavy rain storm. I can easily imagine an hour+ response time in a rural area w/ bad weather. Compound that with the likelihood of other calls and only 1 or 2 crews to work them, necessitating a crew from neighboring area to run that particular call. It's unfortunate, but it happens. I'd guess that the weather played a bigger role in the response time than anything else.

What a horrifying experience - I hope you're starting to feel okay.

I know a lot of people have already posted this, but it doesn't hurt to repeat that from what you describe there wasn't anything you could have done that would have changed the outcome.

A nurse friend of mine had a similar scene in her front yard (young guys driving fast wiped out coming around a corner too fast). She said that she always thought it would be hard to be in a situation like that and not know what to do, but that it was worse knowing what to do and being helpless.

That said, you might want to think about taking a first aid course (including CPR) at some point, if only to help you feel better equipped.

Seeking counselling/debriefing is a really good idea.

  • Author
What a horrifying experience - I hope you're starting to feel okay.

I know a lot of people have already posted this, but it doesn't hurt to repeat that from what you describe there wasn't anything you could have done that would have changed the outcome.

A nurse friend of mine had a similar scene in her front yard (young guys driving fast wiped out coming around a corner too fast). She said that she always thought it would be hard to be in a situation like that and not know what to do, but that it was worse knowing what to do and being helpless.

That said, you might want to think about taking a first aid course (including CPR) at some point, if only to help you feel better equipped.

Seeking counselling/debriefing is a really good idea.

I want to thank all of you for your responses. I feel very welcomed here and enjoy reading what you have to say. I do feel better about the whole accident (it happened on thanksgiving day). I was truley hurt because i felt like i wasnt able to do anything. This is one of the reasons i really want to be a nurse. I want to know what to do and how to do when in a situation like such. I want to help people and be there to comfort the family's of these people and i feel like i've been very strong in this situation and it helps encourage me even more to become a nurse. Thank you all

:)

I want to thank all of you for your responses. I feel very welcomed here and enjoy reading what you have to say. I do feel better about the whole accident (it happened on thanksgiving day). I was truley hurt because i felt like i wasnt able to do anything. This is one of the reasons i really want to be a nurse. I want to know what to do and how to do when in a situation like such. I want to help people and be there to comfort the family's of these people and i feel like i've been very strong in this situation and it helps encourage me even more to become a nurse. Thank you all

:)

I'm glad something positive has come out of this for you. While I was waiting to finish my pre-req's for nursing school, I decided to become an EMT. I had some basic knowledge, b/c I had volunteered in a ER for 3 years as a teenager. My triggering experience? I remember sitting in my living room, hearing a dog bark next door. Peeved, b/c we weren't allowed to have pets. Later on, I heard screaming. I opened my door to find out what was going on, and a young boy with a bloody eye came towards me. I gave him gauze I had in my medicine cabinet to put on it, and went next door to see what was going on. I will never forget walking in, seeing a pitbull with it jaws locked around an older woman's breast. She was screaming "he's tearing my boob off!" over and over. I remember bringing over a big knife, and one girl told me no, not to kill it. She had her hands in the dogs mouth, trying to pry it open, while her roommate, a paraplegic, was pulling on the dogs tail. Thank Go dthe dog didn't turn on her. I ran upstairs while calling 911, and finally got neighbors to come and help. They poured Kool-Aid on the dog, and he let go. Then he chomped down on her arm. I can still remember the crunch. They poured somethign else on him, and while she was running out the door, he got her on the back of her thigh. He finally let go, and we got her outside and the dog inside. I remember holding her up, applying pressure on her arm (she was bleeding badly), and telling her she needed to stay awake. I remember giving a short report to the EMT, then helping the girl in the wheelchair clean blood off of the floor of the apartment.

Long story to say this: That experience made me feel helpless. I could remember small bits of what to do, but really didn't have much of a clue. I took my lack on knowledge and made something of it. I know try to make sure I am prepared for whatever happens. I have a BP cuff, scope, and gloves in the trunk of my car. If I could get IV supplies, I would keep some of those too.

Big props to you for choosing nursing as a career from this experience, rather than running from it. -Andrea

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Currently Reading 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.