NP or PA?

[Reaz, BSN]

I know I’m writing on a nursing forum, but I want advice from both parties since I also asked this on a PA forum.

I am struggling on which to become. I am a new nurse now who is thinking about my options.

Reasons to go PA- I like the medical model approach way more than the nursing model. It is a more extensive and thorough training program and better prepares you for the provider role (IMO.) I have read from numerous sites that if you don’t have a lot of nursing experience, which I don’t, then you won’t come out of NP school feeling super confident (idk if this is the case). I also like the variability and ability to specialize in different areas once you graduate versus picking a speciality at the beginning of NP school. I also think I want to do something in surgery, which is dominated by PAs.

BUT, I am already a nurse, so it is in my nature to think about being an NP. I hear they also have a better job outlook and have more respect because they are better supported by their organization. They also have independence, but that doesn’t matter to me so much.

I am very confused and I would love some advice. I know I am asking on a nursing page, so I understand I will get some biased answers, but please be honest about what you think is right for me.

Thanks!!

[Oldmahubbard]

My understanding is that PA programs are 2 years, full time, in person, B and M, you cannot work, and no exceptions. They are also very, very competitive.

We all know what NP programs are. Total crap by comparison.

Just some thoughts

[FullGlass, BSN, MSN, NP]

25 minutes ago, Oldmahubbard said:

My understanding is that PA programs are 2 years, full time, in person, B and M, you cannot work, and no exceptions. They are also very, very competitive.

We all know what NP programs are. Total crap by comparison.

Just some thoughts

NP programs vary in quality. There are excellent NP programs out there and it is up to the prospective student to do some research to find them. Having worked with PAs, I don't see them as superior to NPs.

PAs do more procedures and are more often found in acute care settings.

NPs were originally developed to provide primary care, although many now work in acute care settings.

As you pointed out, PA school is 2 years of full-time B&M school. Individuals who must work during school would be better served by going to NP school, which can be done part-time.

Personally, I think the NP specialization is great for people who know what they want to do.

[Oldmahubbard]

49 minutes ago, FullGlass said:

NP programs vary in quality. There are excellent NP programs out there and it is up to the prospective student to do some research to find them. Having worked with PAs, I don't see them as superior to NPs.

PAs do more procedures and are more often found in acute care settings.

NPs were originally developed to provide primary care, although many now work in acute care settings.

As you pointed out, PA school is 2 years of full-time B&M school. Individuals who must work during school would be better served by going to NP school, which can be done part-time.

Personally, I think the NP specialization is great for people who know what they want to do.

As usual, you are right on the money and thanks for your contribution.