Getting in a program

Published

I was just wondering what other experiences are across the country, if anyone wants to or feels that they can comment. I talked to a friend the other day about a school we're applying to. The friend tells me that she spoke to someone she knows at the school she used to work with and was told this person would help her by doing interview prep and put a good word in for her to the interviewing panel. From what I gathered, this person knows the interview process well and has a good idea of what to do to help my friend get in. This just made me furious. Am I being too sensitive for thinking this is unfair? School is competitive enough in my oppinion without having some people have an inside line to the interviewing committee. If I can't get in on my own merit because I deserve to be there, then I don't want in, I want to earn my way. What does everyone else think?

Up Vote Up Vote ×
Specializes in I know stuff ;).

Hey Tenn

In a "fair" world i would be furious as well. However, this is common practice both in admissions and in real life jobs.

I guess the only thing i can say is that you have to use whatever resources you have to get what you want. If someone knows a person who went through the interview process or has friends on the admission board they act as a proxy reference. Is it fair, no is it OK sure.

What is worse is that the process works against a person as well. If someone on the interview board knows someone who dosen't like you, that too will weight to some degree, on admissions. Again not fair.

The only way to console yourself about it (or how i did anyway) is to apply to more than one place and remember that one or two people on an admission board dont make the whole decision.

Up Vote Up Vote ×
Hey Tenn

In a "fair" world i would be furious as well. However, this is common practice both in admissions and in real life jobs.

I guess the only thing i can say is that you have to use whatever resources you have to get what you want. If someone knows a person who went through the interview process or has friends on the admission board they act as a proxy reference. Is it fair, no is it OK sure.

What is worse is that the process works against a person as well. If someone on the interview board knows someone who dosen't like you, that too will weight to some degree, on admissions. Again not fair.

The only way to console yourself about it (or how i did anyway) is to apply to more than one place and remember that one or two people on an admission board dont make the whole decision.

I realize you are right in that it can be a help or a hurt to "know" people on the admissions committee. I guess I just see it as being unfair because it seems like certain select people get an easy ride in when others work their butts off to acheive the goal. You give some very thoughtful advice, and it gives me a better perspective on the situation. Thanks.

Up Vote Up Vote ×

TennRN2004

Having served on many admission committees, I can tell you that knowing someone on an interview committee does not guarentee acceptance. If there are 2 canditates equal in all other respects, the vote is more likely to be swayed for the known vs the unknown. However, candidates are still accepted according to their qualifications (GPA, experience, GRE scores, interview skills, recommendations etc). In my experience, a more qualified candidate would not lose a spot to a less qualified candidate just because of who they knew.

Up Vote Up Vote ×

it is very discouraging when i here how hard it is to get in these programs.

Up Vote Up Vote ×
Specializes in ICU, UT knoxville, CRNA Program, 01/07.

When I went through the interview we were told not to disucuss the process so as not to taint their interview process. I took that on the honor system and did not discuss particulars. I wish you the best.

Brian

Up Vote Up Vote ×
Specializes in MICU & SICU.

I would not concern myself with what someone else thinks as a edge that they may have. How does this person who once was on the comittee knows exactly what they are going to ask. Worrying about what someone else is doing will only hurt your preparation. If this person is not fit to be admitted do you really think any percieved edge will get this person in? Take pride in getting in on your on accord, but be aware that word of mouth and who knows who is a common business practice on many different fronts in life.

Up Vote Up Vote ×
+ Join the Discussion