Congrats! Having too many options is a good problem to have. I will give you the same advice I was given as a new grad: ask the recruiter for both units if you can shadow for a half day before you make your decision. When I graduated from nursing school, I was stuck between two ICU positions. Once I got on the units and spent (literally) a couple of hours there, my decision was perfectly clear. Sometimes it's NOT the job description or the hospital's reputation - it's the culture, the acuity, and the people that will set you up for success.