I have a question here. I heard a prehospital provider could have been fired because they asked their neighbors daughter who is at their house more than her own "How is your dad doing". is this a hippa violation. the patient was in police custody outside the hospital and not a patient at that time. the Father was obviously drunk he was yelling the providers name saying " hey that's my neighbor ****, they lives next door to me". so could he have fought this as he feels it was not a violation and they say it is.