Study: Male nurses most likely to leave profession
September 8, 2002 Posted: 8:02 AM EDT (1202 GMT)
PHILADELPHIA (AP) -- Recent graduates of the nation's nursing schools are leaving the profession more quickly than their predecessors, with male nurses bolting at almost twice the rate of their female counterparts, according to a new study.
About 7.5 percent of new male nurses left the profession within four years of graduating from nursing school, compared to 4.1 percent of new female nurses, according to the study by a University of Pennsylvania researcher. It was reported Thursday in the journal Health Affairs.
"In general, nurses are looked down upon, especially by physicians," said Jerome Koss, a nurse since 1978 and an administrator for Fox Chase Cancer Center in Philadelphia. "It's changing but it's still an issue -- and I think men are much less tolerant than women of that kind of treatment."
The research, which looked at data in a national survey of registered nurses conducted by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services in 1992, 1996 and 2000, is the latest to highlight the nationwide nursing shortage.
Tom Foster, a nurse for eight years, said low pay is a big issue for men and women alike, and he questioned whether some men may discover after graduation that they have problems working in a female-dominated field.
"Many men are interested in the technical aspect of nursing and they use nursing as a stepping stone" to more advanced and better-paying jobs in critical care or as nurse anesthetists, said Foster, who also works at Fox Chase.
Though men only make up about 5 percent of the nursing work force nationwide, their departure rates are still a cause for concern, said Bill Cruice, director of the Pennsylvania Association of Staff Nurses and Allied Professionals.
"For men or women, the problem will not be solved until you deal with staffing levels, mandatory overtime, lack of respect and recognition and lack of a decent pension," he said.
Government and medical groups have said that if current trends continue, the nation will face a shortage of half a million nurses by 2020. The nation's nursing corps is aging, nursing school enrollments have been dropping and nearly 2.7 million nurses in the United States aren't actively practicing, according to a government report released earlier this year.
"If new RNs are leaving the profession after only a few years, the shortage is likely to reach crisis proportions sooner rather than later," said Julie Sochalski, associate professor at Penn's School of Nursing and author of the study.
The study also found that the dropout rate for new graduates of both genders is accelerating -- rising from 2 percent of men in 1992 to 7.5 percent in 2000; and 2.7 percent of women in 1992 to 4.1 percent in 2000.
Job satisfaction also differed by gender, with 75 percent of new female nurses reporting they were satisfied with their jobs compared to 67 percent of male nurses. Among nurses established in their careers, 69 percent of women and 60 percent of men reported being satisfied with their jobs.
"Men, I think, want more autonomy in their careers ... they want to be making decisions about their own practice," Koss said. "The profession is changing and there's more room for that than there used to be. Maybe the problem is that the word's not getting out."
The report did not attempt to address why more new nurses, and specifically new male nurses, are leaving. But Sochalski said it shows the importance of looking for the reasons.
Copyright 2002 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Sep 10, '02
It's not fair, but I have the impression that male doctors and most patients give male RNs more respect and trust than their female counterparts. Kind of a transference from the overwhelmingly male physician population, I think.
I have also noticed a predominence of male RNs in situations such as ER and psyc. Why is that -- do testosterone-laddened nurses avoid direct bedside care?
Just wondering. I'm a dude currently in nursing school -- wondering what's up with guys bailing-out of the biz.
Sep 10, '02
I am admittedly in no position to interject here, though i wish I could speak from more actual experience/tours of duty. I just been a floating CNA with a home floor for 5 months. I am going to nursing school, RN2004.
I like to think this is mis-information and/or pointblank propaganda. Male or female, it doesn't make a bit of difference who is doing the right thing at the right time. I don't know if women are less apt handle higher levels of what we call stress. Women and men are equal.
As far as guys leaving, I hope its true, which will make me more of a stand out. I all ready stand out because of MY BRIGHT YELLOW NIKE ROC-SHOX CROSS TRAINERS WITH THE SUPER POWER !!!!
Sep 10, '02
Maybe more male nurses are in ER because they are adrenaline junkies like I used to be when my body was still producing copious amounts of testosterone. Alas, no more.
Sep 10, '02
A lot of women nurses leave the strong impression that they have a need to be approved of (by patients, visitors, coworkers, docs, etc.). This puts them in a position, in the eyes of many people, of weakness--to be disrespected. Men who leave that same strong impression tend not to be respected either.
Some men, like myself, were less willing to put up with the permeating abuse, absence of leadership, lack of support, and incompetent management often found in bedside nursing than the women nurses who remained there (by definition, since they remained).
Last edit by sjoe on Sep 10, '02