CNA while going through nursing school? good or bad idea?

Published

Hello all,

I having been taking many science courses in preparation for possibly entering a nursing program... but I have not made a definitive decision as to whether this is the path I want to go. I am just not sure whether I would enjoy it and I find it is very hard to know for sure whether I would like a job until I am actually doing it. This would be a career change for me. I want something that is interesting, pays well and has flexibility.

Would being a CNA give me a good perspective as far as whether this is the right career for me? It would at least get me into the medical field and I would get a feel for the environment. I know how hard CNA's must work and I have the utmost respect for people that do this job, but I also am concerned that CNA's probably do a lot of things nurses don't deal with on a daily basis... and I worry it would not be a fair representation. I am concerned that they do a lot more of the less desirable tasks..and that this could turn me off to nursing and won't be a fair representation.

I really would like to get a feel for the environment and whether it is something I would like. I don't want to get a distorted view of nursing... but I want to gain experience and make some money while I am in school. I understand even as a nurse I would have to do some things that are not pleasurable, but I don't want to unfairly bias my opinion if I did a job that really wasn't comparable at all. I want to also get into the environment to meet people in the field.

Does anyone have any suggestions? Also where would I take a program in MA (live in south eastern part of MA)? The only one I know of is the red cross program and this is a combination home health aide/Nurses aide program and costs 800 dollars. If people think this program is worth it then I would pay and do it... but I don't know that I need the home health aide training unless it would open up more opportunities somehow.

Thanks for your advice.

Up Vote Up Vote ×
Specializes in Medicine.

Without a doubt, it is the best thing for you. Nursing is one of those jobs that you either love or hate, and it's best to determine that before you start the program and realize that this is not for you. I would recommend working in a hospital for this experience, as sometimes a nursing home can leave a sour taste in your mouth.

As for where you can get that training, a red cross head quarters would be your best bet. The cost of the course may be a little pricey, but it will save you money down the road if you realize that this is something you don't want to do.

It will also give you an edge in school because you will already have exposure to patient's and feel comfortable working around them, which is sometimes half the battle. I worked as an aide all throughout my senior year of high school and all throughout my four years of nursing school, and I felt I had a HUGE advantage over some of the other classmates without any experience! Anyhow, good luck in your choice, and feel free to ask any questions. ;)

P.S. Working as an aide allows you to have flexible hours and work on the weekends if need be, and the money isn't terrible. A lot of places accommadate you if they know you're in school.

Up Vote Up Vote ×

thanks so much for your advice... i really appreciate it.

I know the job is tough and the money is not great (CNA) but it probably would be a good experience and really give me a feel for the Industry.

Can you tell me what the pay is for a CNA in MA? I am hoping it is over 10 an hour... but I am worried it may not be. I really would love to hear it is at least 15 but i think I am dreaming.

Do hospitals pay better than LTC?

Thanks again.... :)

Up Vote Up Vote ×

It would at least get me into the medical field and I would get a feel for the environment. I know how hard CNA's must work and I have the utmost respect for people that do this job, but I also am concerned that CNA's probably do a lot of things nurses don't deal with on a daily basis... and I worry it would not be a fair representation. I am concerned that they do a lot more of the less desirable tasks..and that this could turn me off to nursing and won't be a fair representation.

I agree 100% with the advice that ANB85 has given, but I just wanted to add that while nursing assistants do a lot more of the "dirty work" on a daily basis, nurses still do perform those duties. Bed baths, mouth care, bed changes, toileting, etc. is all part of basic nursing care and sometimes there isn't an aide around to help with these tasks. Also, some units do not utilize aides and the nurses perform all aspects of patient care. A bed bath is a great time to do a thorough head to toe assesment and skin check on patients. As a CNA, you will learn how to perform direct patient care, interact with patients and families, use equipment, etc. While its not the same as being a nurse, I think working as a CNA would give you a good taste of what the environment is like and whether or not you could see yourself in healthcare. Good luck!!!

Up Vote Up Vote ×
Specializes in Medicine.

Hi there,

CNA pay is definitely over 10/hour. I live in Western Ma, and work at a small community hosptial, and the base pay is 10$. Places closer to Boston are going to definitely pay more. And, if you work per diem, the rate will be a little higher because there are no benefits involved. Hope that helped!

As for LTC pay, I am unsure, but my initial thought is that it is going to be higher.

Up Vote Up Vote ×
Specializes in Sub-Acute/Psychiatric/Detox.

I'd say between $10-$13 for LTC, and $10+ for Hospital. Be aware hospital CNA jobs are very hard to get compared to LTC jobs.

Up Vote Up Vote ×

Hi there, this is the first reply ive done. Ive been a cna for 20 years now in long term care, mainly alzheimers unit. You will know quickly if the health field is the right avenue or not for you by working as a cna. I honestly think we all have gifts we are given at birth, patience, kindness, etc. these definately are qualities you need to have to be able to cope in the health field. I love what i do and have the opportunity now to be in school for my lpn license. Follow your heart, if you go the route of cna first and it doesn't work out at least it isn't as costly as being enrolled in a nursing program. Good luck in whatever you decide upon. Helping others is such a great way to earn a paycheck, its the bonus that goes with the health field:-)

Up Vote Up Vote ×
+ Join the Discussion