Re: Racism in Healthcare --- Originally Posted by wowza
1)3) You cannot just make a wild claim like discrimination in health care without backing it up with at least some proof or even a vignette. How are African Americans discriminated against under the current system? Are they denied care just because they are black? (no) Are they treated poorly because they are black? (no) Are they denied the ability to buy insurance because they are black? (no) Are they kept from trying to maintain a healthy lifestyle because they are black? (no). So how are the "discriminated" against?
Perhaps you can provide a source supporting your claims that African Americans are
not discriminated against in the current system. There have been quite a number of studies showing that there
are significant disparities in our system that affect services and outcomes for African Americans, even when the data is adjusted so that comparisons are only being made among individuals with comparable income, insurance coverage, etc. Here are a few summary reports:
http://www.ahrq.gov/research/disparit.htm http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm5401a1.htm http://www.iom.edu/Object.File/Maste...isparities.pdf http://www.aetna.com/about/aoti/aetn...sparities.html
However, I don't see how this question relates to "Gates-gate." No, I don't think it's "clear" that the 911 caller and arresting officers are "racists" and I don't think it's "plain" that Gates was "profiled" because he's African American. I'm not saying that I'm sure those things are
NOT true -- they're certainly possible -- just that I don't think
anyone who wasn't there really knows what happened, based on the very limited information that has been released so far. And I think it was a mistake for President Obama to make such a strong, specific comment on a situation he knew nothing (or, at least,
very little) about, although it's understandable, I guess, given that he knows Gates personally.
Returning to healthcare, I'm as big a supporter of healthcare reform as anyone, but, since the current racial/ethnic disparities appeared to be based on attitudes and beliefs of providers as much as anything else, I'm not sure that changes in healthcare funding or delivery are necessarily going to improve that situation -- the problem is a lot more subtle and complicated. I definitely share the OP's hope for a day (soon, I hope) of true equality in this country, however!
Nursing News