TV shows and movies that are ruined, because you know better

Nurses Humor

Published

So many TV shows and movies take place, at least in part, in a medical setting. When you're a nurse, you automatically notice the severe errors in the scenery, which ruins the show. Or maybe it's just me.

I was watching the very first episode of ER (as a rerun, this is fairly recently) where the nurse- what was her name? I'm getting old- OD'd and was brought into the ER on a stretcher. I jumped off the couch and started shouting, "Chest tubes?!? She has two Atrium chest tubes there. For a drug overdose???"

It seems like the directors of these shows assume that the more medical-looking stuff they throw in there, the more realistic it will seem.

On TV, the "patient" almost always has his O2 cannula on incorrectly. And I can't count how many times I've seen the actor-patient surrounded by medical equipment that is totally irrelevant to his illness. Oh, there's a vent nearby, and some vent tubing on the bed, for no apparent reason. Sometimes you'll see an EKG monitor in the background and the rhythm displayed there totally doesn't match what's going on with the "patient". (Many times, it's a fatal rhythm, but the patient is alert and talking.)

And the IV pumps/ bags etc... It's all wrong, all wrong, and I can't stand it.

Also, I'm a huge Stephen King fan, but in two of his books he has patients who are on ventilators who suddenly wake up and start talking... with the ventilator still in place. (The Dead Zone, and Desperation.)

It also chaps my ### when the nurse is wearing whites, with a skimpy white skirt, with a white nurse's cap... in a modern day setting. (If the movie is taking place in 1970, that's different, but I'm talking about shows set in modern times.) Inevitably, if the nurse says anything at all, it is something stupid.

Has anyone else been irritated or enraged by things like this? Or am I just over the edge?

Specializes in School Nurse.

I love Greys just for the entertainment of the storyline, not the medical accuracy at all

But i just watched one where Karev was talking to one of the attendings and said heres your new patiet oh and by the way he peed himself (little boy) and I CLEANED IT ALL UP FOR YOU.

Hahahahahahahahhahhahaha but no that would never happen. Heres the real world scenario....

Karev: Heres your new patient and by the way he peed himself but I called in the tech to change him, even though it wasnt the tech's patient and I have perfectly capable hands. :)

I can chuckle or groan about most of the misinformation the public receives from medical shows. What I hate is when someone is seriously injured and friends or family rush them to the hospital in their car instead of calling an ambulance. That really gives bad ideas to the public. On a less important note , it annoys me when the patient is discharged and the family pushes them out in a wheel chair by themselves. No mention of discharge instructions and who is going to ensure that wheelchair gets back inside! PS. why do my paragraphs get removed when I submit my reply!

Just watched a show recently where a patient was in surgery...for her eye. She codes. The 5 docs in the room (yes only docs) look at each other and one says, "We are losing her! What do we do?" Then they all continue to stare at each other before the commercial break. OMG, I just about lost it! haha "What do we do!" Make sure my doc never says that if I code.

Ugh HATE it when they shock through clothing. I also don't get the whole stabbing someone in the heart with epi to bring them back to life. And they so magically shoot up and start talking. A team of 4+ docs seeing the pt in ED and following their care though the entire hospital with minimal help from other staff. Yeah. Right. House. Although I still like to watch it.

I was just remembering a time when I went to see a movie with a friend/fellow nurse. Good thing the movie theater was empty because we kept laughing at all their silly mistakes! Too bad I forgot which movie it was.

Specializes in Ambulatory Surgery, Ophthalmology, Tele.

One time while flipping through the channels on tv, I came across a show called Hawthorne. In a scene Jada Pinkett Smith (as an RN) is walking out of a room where there is an emergent situation in the back ground. As she leaves the room discussing very important information with someone (dramatic setup for the rest of the show, I am sure- and of coure a nurse would walk away from a code...yeah..that's real life...sure). The doctor yells out "His potassium is low, Push potassium stat!" :eek:

Specializes in Med-Surg.

The CPR thing gets me EVERY time...I dont think Ive ever seen a tv show or movie where they do it right.

On a slight side note, you guys keep talking about side-rails being down and all, here in Quebec they are actually working on us using side-rails less because it is actually a form of restraint for the patient, and a dangerous one at that for the acrobats that decide to jump over in their confusion!

Specializes in ER/SICU/Med-Surg/Ortho/Trauma/Flight.

On a side note about hawthorne, shes the cno, would you like to tell me where we all can find a cno that is actually going to come to the floor and actually work, let alone helping us code someone, hah, give me a break, the day this really happens I will need to be coded, because I am gonna have a massive m.i.

Specializes in Trauma, ER, ICU, CCU, PACU, GI, Cardiology, OR.
i came across this book in a local bookstore last week and it made some pretty interesting points. sure it might have been a little preachy at times, but overall it gave me something to think about.

it's called saving lives: why the media's portrayal of nursing puts us all at risk

take a look at http://www.truthaboutnursing.org/savinglives/

313rn, i received that same book back in 2009 as a gift from a colleague of mine, and yes it held my interest till the end. btw i love your avatar :cool:

Specializes in Trauma, ER, ICU, CCU, PACU, GI, Cardiology, OR.

back to the post on hand. needless to say, this is the reason why my non-medical friends hate to watch medical sitcoms with me, because i begin to lol even if the actor is portraying a dead pt. i can spot the errors :lol2:

Specializes in 3 years MS/Tele, 10 years total ICU, 5 travel.

Two words: Doctors. Bedpans.

My favorite was one time on Greys, I think it was Arizona, told a patient they had "psoriasis" of the liver instead of "cirrhosis."

I cracked up..

Specializes in Geriatrics, Trach Care, Diabetes.

I had a doctor in real life that actually came in and did all his own vital signs!! I was about 20 then and I was astonished!! That doctor is still around and has too full of a load of patients to take anymore. He was great he was a doctor for all the right reasons. What a gem.

Specializes in Geriatrics, Trach Care, Diabetes.
Have you noticed that NO ONE on Er ever washes their hands?????!!!!!

I guess they omit that because it would make for boring tv. But yeah they can easily have a dialogue while that happened! I have 17 years food service experience, and then my 5+ nursing. I could teach a hand washing class in a coma. I just want to say that the TV shows are really an accurate depiction of what happens in restaurants and in health care from my experience. Just to give a very accurate picture of what goes on in regarding hand washing. Worked at Cracker Barrel while in Nursing school. Sunday morning, 17 servers ONE hand washing sink...I NEVER had to wait in line to wash my hands!!! I was soo very grossed out. Flash forward I am now a LPN and honestly they all just rely on hand sanitizer, again gross. I feel like hand sanitizer is similar to what we experience in the world of antibiotic resistant bacteria, I can not believe that those decades old sanitizing formulas are truly effective anymore. Thank you for washing your hands! You are a rare one! :)

+ Add a Comment