What She Couldn't Tell You

You've all had that patient...the mom with the frequent flyer child, and you want to scream with frustration because she's here again. Maybe she can't tell you why she keeps coming back. Maybe her behavior and lack of eye-contact makes your teeth itch. Did you ever ask? Did you look beyond your own exhaustion and frustration and really see her? How much do any of us really see the people we talk to, sit by, or care for? Nurses Announcements Archive Article

We've all met this type of mom before. It's 2330, her 8 year old daughter is struggling to breathe, and you know for a fact you saw them two weeks ago for the same thing. You also know for a fact you gave her a prescription for an inhaler, a follow-up appointment with a pediatrician for asthma, and got the information for applying for state aid for medical assistance. Yet, there they are, the child anxious and pale, the mother unable to make eye-contact and answering in quiet, short statements.

A little eye-rolling as you walk into the room helps you keep your tongue civil during the H&P. Definitely an asthma attack, the kind you had educated this mom about avoiding and preventing two weeks ago. You sigh in frustration (and a wee bit of anger) without realizing it, but the mother does. She shrinks a little more in the chair, stares at the floor at little harder, and tightens her hand around her daughter's hand. Her behavior sets your teeth on edge, and you hurry out of the room so you don't say anything you think will get yourself in trouble later.

As you head down the hall to let the on-call know that FF#3 is waiting for a neb, you shake your head that just about anyone can have kids nowadays, and wonder at that mom's gall to come in and be so diffident when it is clearly her fault that child is having another attack. You make sure to share your opinion with the nurses at the station. Venting helps.

Meanwhile in that room, a very anxious mother, who is struggling with an Atlas-sized load of guilt, tries to sooth her anxious child while they both wait uncomfortably for the doctor. Mom knows what you think of her. You aren't as unbiased and neutral as you thought. She can't tell you why they are here on a cold snowy night, at least not straight out, and you didn't ask.

She can't tell you that her husband has threatened to kill her and the daughter on numerous occasions if she ever thought about leaving him.

She can't tell you that he broke two ribs and tore out a chunk of her hair the size of a golf-ball when she tried saving up money for the daughter's birthday presents. He needed that money, there was beer to be bought.

She can't tell you that he disabled her car four times in the past two weeks while he was out drinking, and one of those times fell squarely on the day of the child's appointment.

She can't tell you that he routinely takes all of the money out of her purse, and she can barely feed her daughter, let alone get medication for her.

She can't tell you that he's a twice convicted felon, and because he won't leave, and won't let her leave, she can't get federal or state aid, because one of those felonies involved drugs.

She can't tell you these things, because he's out in the car, partially drunk, with a gun hidden under the seat, and if she takes what he thinks is too long, this might be the night he uses it.

So she hides. She does what she can, and tries to keep her daughter and herself alive. She takes all of your judgement and frustration and internalizes it, reinforces her belief that she is a horrible person, a horrible mother, and deserves every little bit of scorn and distaste heaped upon her. She knows all this, and yet she brought the daughter to the ER anyways, knowing that you will still care for the daughter, even if you hate the mother. She trusts in your care, your skill, and your oath to care for the ill. She pays you in nickles, dimes, and her self-esteem.

She might not have been able to tell you, and you didn't ask.

Specializes in Hospice.
Putting aside the issue of possible abuse that may or may not be a factor in this case, if we had national healthcare at least this child would have an inhaler, but instead many people are forced to go without medicare care and medicine over cost! It shouldn't be this way and if we had routine national healthcare like almost every other civilized country it wouldn't leave a child without medication! I have asthma and since they changed over CFB's and ozone it now costs $50+ for an albuterol inhaler and combivent and all the other prevention inhalers are even more! Other countries provide health care and medicine for their people practically free, but not the good old USA where profit has to be involved in every transaction so that the for profits and pharmaceutical industry can get their cut!

Instead of a sane, fair, humane universal healthcare system, we have a patchwork system where you have to beg and plead and jump thru hoops for healthcare or spend thousands out of your pocket in premiums and even then thousands more if you actually need healthcare! If you're poor and without health insurance you can stand in line at a free clinic and hope they see you before they close for the day or run to the ER where you can't be turned away! At the very least the hospital should be able to provide an inhaler for the child and then charge the govt medicaid program! A person can die without a rescue inhaler, especially children as asthma is even more dangerous in children!

As for abuse, it is very sad that this can sometimes be an issue, but it doesn't have to be! In America women are allowed to work and live independently of a man, unlike other countries where women are unable to go to school or work or live free! Also there are shelters for women escaping abusive relationships if they would only take the first step and get help and get away from an abusive person. If women would recognize their own power and ability they would realize they don't need a man. I see a lot of desperate women who will put up with just about anything to not be alone! A relationship might be the ideal but only if the man is a decent human being in the first place, otherwise you are better off being single and safe!

That's the problem the abuser has taken away the power by being physically and psychologically abusive. If you tell a child over and over he/she is stupid they will eventually believe you. The same is true for a person in a DV situation, if you tell them enough times they are worthless and nobody wants them, follow that up with a few punches for good measure and then do it regularly they will eventually believe it too. Then don't forget that after the abuser does those things he will often show some type of affection to make the person think that they do love them. It is a vicious cycle and as nurses we need to be educated on the patterns and s/s of abuse.

Specializes in allergy and asthma, urgent care.

This was a very moving piece, and serves as a good reminder that things are not always what they seem to be.

I'd like to thank everyone for their responses. Yes, even the responses that might not have agreed with my point of view, because with that input we were able to achieve what I had hoped - an open dialogue about domestic violence and nursing's responsibility.

I'd like to say one thing to the few that disapproved of the mother. While I am so glad that you have never had the horrible fortune of being in a "relationship" like this, nor have you been intimately exposed to one, I am saddened that you are unwilling or incapable of sympathy and withholding judgment. The nurse in the story may perhaps be your mirror image.

To know that some have read this story and were deeply moved or driven to change their nursing practices makes me profoundly grateful.

That woman was my mother.

Specializes in ICU.

That woman was my mother.

Ohmygoodness...I did not see that coming...I am so sorry that you and your mother went through that. Thank you so much for sharing your story...for humanizing domestic violence...you can just never know what the person in front of you is dealing with in private.

Specializes in allergy and asthma, urgent care.
To those that have no sympathy for the woman in this story - I am happy for you, as it shows that you have most likely never suffered physical or psychological abuse. I know from experience that it can be very frustrating to see women in these situations who seem to "refuse to help themselves." But unless we ourselves are in the same situation, we have no way of knowing how it feels. Fear, guilt, depression, low self-esteem - all of these emotions/conditions can be very crippling. Saying "Why doesn't she just go to a shelter?" is the equivalent of telling the patient with severe clinical depression, "Why don't you just snap out of it? Take a shower! Get a job!" It is just not that simple.

Perhaps think of turning your righteous anger into some kind of purposeful action. Get educated about how to help these women. Then go do it.

^^^^ This

This made me tear up. Even more so when you said the women was your mother. It's so heartbreaking and I send hugs to you and anyone that's ever been in that situation.

Specializes in Long Term Care, Maternal Child, NICU.

One time I was sleeping and I had a dream about meeting a husband/father like this, and, as the nurse, I was able to play a game with him. It was called "guess what's in the syringe." And I gave him an injection...best dream ever.

Specializes in Hospice.
Definitely. If my husband is drunk in the car with a gun, I sure as heck am not putting my daughter back in with him so he can kill all three of us. The first thing I would do would be say something and get the cops over there. I have no sympathy for people who actively endanger their children and themselves.

What if the husband is the COP? When someone finds themselves in a domestic violence situation it is very bad, when the offender is a "trusted" police officer it is even worse. The victim is told over and over that he could kill her at anytime and get away with it, because he knows how to do it without leaving any evidence. Anybody see the movie or read about Drew Peterson?

Specializes in Emergency Room, Trauma ICU.
What if the husband is the COP? When someone finds themselves in a domestic violence situation it is very bad when the offender is a "trusted" police officer it is even worse. The victim is told over and over that he could kill her at anytime and get away with it, because he knows how to do it without leaving any evidence. Anybody see the movie or read about Drew Peterson?[/quote']

So what's the point? If they never leave, if they're prisoners why bother? Why ask the questions, why have DV shelters, why anything? Because it's not a life sentence, people do leave they do go on, that is why we have all these resources. But unless the people ask for help we can't do anything, we aren't mind readers.

Specializes in Hospice.
So what's the point? If they never leave, if they're prisoners why bother? Why ask the questions, why have DV shelters, why anything? Because it's not a life sentence, people do leave they do go on, that is why we have all these resources. But unless the people ask for help we can't do anything, we aren't mind readers.

Not all people leave, some are killed. You are right, we are not mind readers, but sometimes just taking the extra little step when you suspect DV may actually save a life.

On admission we ask something along the line of ... violence is an increasing alarm in our community, are you currently a victim of violence or abuse? I have seen multiple nurses ask this when the spouse or s.o. is present, what's the point? I have also asked this question and the patient hesitates, UHHH that right there might be a sign, not always, but sometimes.

Have I seen women go back to the abuser? Yes, my daughter did it at least four times. Did I call the cops? Sure did and when she denied the abuse to the officer she was hit again because her mother was a nosy bi*@h.

The relationship finally ended when he gave her an STD and then blamed her for cheating on him (his other girlfriend was pregnant by the way).

All I am saying is DV is not cut and dry, and I ask all nurses to not pre-judge someone in the situation.

Excellent post! A real eye opener all nurses should read and consider! Sometimes we assume other people's situations are similar to our own. However, nothing can be further from the truth. Your topic will serve as a reminder to be very cautious prior to casting judgment on a situation. Even though many ED triage forms include questions regarding patient safety and abuse. Many times the abused person is experiencing tremendous amounts of fear and deny that abuse is occurring. I am certain cases very similar to this one occur more times than we think.

Specializes in Dialysis.
Definitely. If my husband is drunk in the car with a gun, I sure as heck am not putting my daughter back in with him so he can kill all three of us. The first thing I would do would be say something and get the cops over there. I have no sympathy for people who actively endanger their children and themselves.

From someone who has been in an abusive relationship, I pray to God that you are never in one, and have no one to give you emotional support. I used to say the same thing until I was there myself. Now, I see how easily a manipulative person can work anyone, strong or weak. Remember, it could happen to you. No matter what you say. I had all the family and financial support in the world. An abuser learns how to shut you off from that. And as far as the felony part, you can't line up services until you are gone from the situation, and not everyone has the finances to leave and wait for the services to kick in. And there aren't shelters in every area. And trust me, not all shelters are safe, if they do exist......It's easy to say "just leave", but 20 years later, I still 'hide' from him.......