A Plea to Nurses Everywhere

A plea for nurses everywhere that arose after a drive home reflection. Conflict is as much a part of our work environment as medication administration. Does it really have to be? We can choose our attitudes and begin to treat our coworkers like we treat our patients. With respect. Nurses Announcements Archive Article

I don't seem to process everything that I see, hear and do at work until I am home. My lack of reflection until later might have something to do with running around like a Looney Tunes character for eight or more hours caring for the sick. It is difficult to be reflective when life has to be lived so much in the moment.

But after the last IV has been hung, the last lab value dealt with, the last medication given and the last note written, as I drive home, fragments of my day begin to surface as I try to unwind.

I have different "topics", I guess you could call it, that I mull over as I drive depending on the week or the day.

Some days as I drive home I am reflecting on my assessment skills. Other days I am reflecting on my patient education skills. Sometimes I think about a new disease I learned about, or a new drug.

There is always room for improvement and I often wonder if I would go back and approach a certain situation differently.

I don't always reflect about nursing: there are some shifts where I drive home listening to the radio and trying NOT to think about anything that I did that day.

I have noticed lately, however, that a lot of my reflections on the drive home have to do with communication. Not nurse to patient communication, but staff communication.

Nurse to nurse communication.

Nurse to provider communication.

And quite often, what I am reflecting on is the negative communication that I see.

I know that this topic is not a new one. It has been discussed from many angles by many people more qualified than I. But I would like to show you, if I could, some things that I have seen in over a few weeks time. I imagine that you have seen similar situations.

I have seen and heard:

  • Staff nurses raising their voices (ok, screaming) at a charge nurse at the beginning of a shift because they didn't like their assignment (which, by the way, was not an unfair assignment). And no, I am not the charge nurse.
  • A student calling a health care provider, who spoke sharply at the student after a suggestion was made. The student was tearful as she got off the phone. When the healthcare provider came to the floor, she was incredulous that the student had been upset, because she thought she was just explaining to the student why she would not do what was suggested.
  • A nurse yelling at someone calling to give her report that "I will call you back when I am ready" and slamming the phone down.
  • Another nurse yelling at a pharmacy tech over the phone when an order wasn't right and again slamming the phone down.
  • A doctor trying to explain a unique diagnosis he felt a patient had to a nurse who then replied "So? Am I supposed to be impressed?"
  • Nurses rolling their eyes at dietary techs, housekeepers, etc. who didn't do something they needed help with the minute they needed it.
  • A doctor speaking curtly to a pharmacist about a lab value and then hanging up.

And I couldn't tell you about all of the little jabs that I have seen oncoming nurses give to off coming nurses during report. Quite often between 'older' nurses and 'younger' nurses over nitpicking things that don't amount to a hill of beans.

I understand that we work in stressful environments. We have to get things done. We can't always be worried about the other person being offended, and yes, some people are a little bit too sensitive.

But when this behavior is discussed, we seem to shrug our shoulders and say "Oh well, nurses eat their young. That is just the way it is. People shouldn't get offended so easily."

When I first graduated from nursing school and started in the workplace, I couldn't believe how vicious some nurses were to other nurses.

Trying to figure it out, I mentioned the phrase "Nurses eat their young" to my mother, who has no healthcare background at all. I had heard that phrase many times and it was just a matter of fact to me. "Well you know what they say, nurses eat their young" I mentioned to her offhandedly.

And she was shocked. I mean really shocked. As in stopped what she was doing shocked.

"What a horrible thing to say!" she said aghast. "That is just awful!"

She was incredulous that such a concept existed.

And so we should be.

I have whole chapters in some of my nursing books dedicated to conflict management. There are many great tips in those chapters. But isn't it sad that those chapters have to exist?

There is truth to horizontal violence in the workplace. But interestingly enough, I see a lot of lateral violence. Perhaps more that horizontal.

It's not just Doctors screaming at nurses I see. I see nurses screaming at Doctors. I see nurses screaming at nurses.

I see everything.

And usually I feel like just standing up and saying to my co-workers what my mother would say to me and my siblings when I was young: "Just be nice!"

I know that this topic has so much more involved than just 'being nice.' I know that sometimes, if you are too nice, you will get walked on and the job might not get done.

But theories and sayings like horizontal violence, nurses eating their young, stressful work environments aside, why can't we just be nice?

We DON'T have to disrespect other departments when they are giving us report. We DON'T have to get frustrated at the pharmacy tech because of a system error. We CAN check our tone of voice when we speak to other members of the team, including students.

We can THINK before we speak and we can CONTROL our emotions, and set the phone down gently.

We CAN respect a physician who wants to explain something interesting.

We CAN enjoy the challenge of a different assignment for the shift, and we DON'T have to yell to get what we want.

We are adults. And we are nurses. We need to care enough for the other person to check our stressed out, negative, horrible side at the door and care for those we work with as much as we care for our patients.

I am not telling you to be a doormat. When you need to stand up for yourself, stand up for yourself! But think before you act.

We should be just as shocked at the statement "Nurses eat their young" as my non-healthcare mother was.

Nurses don't just eat their young. They eat each other and everyone around them.

Let's stop.

Think about all of the conflict that you see on your next drive home like I have.

Are you part of it? Do you have to be?

How does it make you feel? Can you change?

Is there something that you need to do to change?

Maybe you are burned out.

I don't know. I just see the behavior.

But since I have not stood up on the desk at the nurses' station and shouted this as loud as I could, I will just say it here.

Please, just be nice.

Specializes in Emergency/Cath Lab.

To the nurses that scream at me that they wont take report....we have ways to fix that. Next time I guarantee you will be nicer and state a reason you cant take report as opposed to just yelling at me.

Screaming, OP? In a 9-year career as a nurse I have never witnessed screaming.

And I think "shock" at unprofessional behavior probably stems from some degree of naivete about people in general, or a belief that somehow nurses are set apart from the rest of the population.

The "shock" was not at unprofessional behavior-that is to be expected everywhere. The shock was that there was such a commonly known phrase such as "Nurses eat their young." She has not been the only one of my non-nursing acquaintances to express surprise at such a phrase that is well known in nursing circles.

And I am glad for you that you have never witnessed screaming. You are not in the 48%. :) http://www.nursingworld.org/Mobile/Nursing-Factsheets/lateral-violence-and-bullying-in-nursing.html

I'm sorry you have to deal with this. I work in a hospital and though I occasionally deal with a grumpy coworkers (from various disciplines), we have a great working environment. I have had an "older" nurse do something for me so I can finish my sandwich and I have had a doc that was nice when I mistakenly called him or her.

I think why our environment is like that is because we all see each other as family. If you think about it, sometimes we see our coworkers just as much, if not more, than we see our family. When you think of each other that way, it's easier to care about your behavior.

Specializes in PICU, NICU, L&D, Public Health, Hospice.
...I think why our environment is like that is because we all see each other as family. If you think about it, sometimes we see our coworkers just as much, if not more, than we see our family. When you think of each other that way, it's easier to care about your behavior.

Sometimes the rudest behavior can be seen exchanged between close family members...just sayin

Specializes in Med-Surg, Tele, DOU.

To the OP, what have you chosen to do regarding the behaviors you have witnessed. Who have you reported the violence to? Have you documented what you've seen? Have you spoken with your Human Resources Department to have all staff throughout the organization re-educated regarding appropriate behavior? I am asking because, I too have seen exactly what you are writing about. I finally started speaking up. I am also more cognizant of when I am "losing control due to my own personal frustrations." There is much to learn and share from this topic.

It really is a shame that you have to work in an environment like that.

I work in case management. Before that I was a Public Health Nurse working in a community clinic. In 6 years I've NEVER seen a shred of what you talk about. All the nurses I've worked with have been respectful, professional and like family to one another. ALL of them. Please don't blanket-statement all nurses like this, we don't all work in hospitals.

I understand AN is geared mostly toward acute care/floor/med Surg nursing, but a huge percentage of nurses work elsewhere, in environments other than hospitals. And that is where what you describe seems to happen most. It's important to point that out.

I would LOVE to get a job where you work!

I don't see this degree of severity of attitude, but I definitely see some. I am a student and for some reason, the nurses in the nursery on my maternity rotation were the worst! I remember there was an infant wearing a diaper and in a pram crying and I knew a circ had just occurred, so I said to the nurse; "Is that the baby who just had the circ done?" She looked at me like I was partially retarded and said "THAT, is a girl." I just wanted to die laughing inside because I thought to myself, well if I could see the baby's genitals through the diaper than I would not have asked. There were no other obvious indicators pointing towards the baby's sex.

I guess it really just depends where it is and the general attitude of the unit and hospital.

Specializes in Oncology.
To the nurses that scream at me that they wont take report....we have ways to fix that. Next time I guarantee you will be nicer and state a reason you cant take report as opposed to just yelling at me.

Ok, I'm curious, I'll bite. What ways would those be?

Specializes in burn ICU, SICU, ER, Trauma Rapid Response.
Ok, I'm curious, I'll bite. What ways would those be?

*** Find them alone in the parking lot and "explain" to them why it's inappropiate to ever scream at me. Don't know what ThatGuy does but works for me.

Specializes in Emergency & Trauma/Adult ICU.
The "shock" was not at unprofessional behavior-that is to be expected everywhere. The shock was that there was such a commonly known phrase such as "Nurses eat their young." She has not been the only one of my non-nursing acquaintances to express surprise at such a phrase that is well known in nursing circles.

And I am glad for you that you have never witnessed screaming. You are not in the 48%. :) Lateral Violence and Bullying in Nursing

I am somewhat familiar with Cheryl Dellasega's work on this topic.

The 2003 ISMP survey to which 1,565 nurses responded - 48% reported "strong verbal abuse". (52% apparently did not)

Intimidation: Practitioners speak up about this unresolved problem (Part I)

There were 2.4 million registered nurses in the US in 2003 (Women's Bureau (WB) - Statistics on Registered Nurses) I'll leave it to someone better versed in statistics than I am to determine the validity of a sample size of 0.065%.

"Screaming" is not a term I find in the survey summary -- and I cannot necessarily interpret all "strong verbal abuse" to be "screaming".

I believe the semantics are important. Screaming is a very different behavior than various other forms of jerkiness.

I certainly do not deny the existence of unprofessional behavior in general, or bullying specifically. But you yourself noted that your original post was "not necessarily reflective" of your work environment as a whole.

Specializes in burn ICU, SICU, ER, Trauma Rapid Response.

We should also consider when one of our co-workers finder herself under extreme stress and in a moment of frusteration lashes out at another vs the person who is simply a jerk and seems to enjoy making other feel diminished or hurt or intimidated. The first could happen to nearly any of us. The second should not be tolerated.

Think about it: If a patient screams at you, it is not pleasant but we, as professionals, continue to care for the "screaming patient". (Oh yes, the one in Room 10.) When another professional nurse screams at you, under any circumstances, that person needs to be reported immediately.