Nurses Helping Nurses
allnurses Network: Central | Jobs | Books | Newsletter
allnurses: A Nursing Community for Nurses
Home General News Blogs Articles Students Region Specialty Degrees F.A.Q.
Neuro Intensive Care Nursing /

Neuro ICU - Do you talk to brain-dead patients?



Did You Know?
allnurses is the largest community for nurses on the web. We now have over 385,810 members! Join today to network with other nurses, laugh, share, and much more.
Page 6 of 23 < 12345 6 7891011 > Last »

No. 50
from Kyriaka
Old May 23, 2004, 07:36 PM

Perhaps the organ procurement agency was a little overzealous in your case, I can't say because I wasn't there. But usually they don't talk to the family unless the docs, RNs, etc. feel there isn't any hope of meaningful recovery. Maybe there was a small miracle in your case.
_____________
Part of the problem here was having no concept of cultural differences. You would never ever approach an Orthodox family about this. The organ people pretty much were asking my family was it ok to mutilate my children (and me). And make money at the same time!

Are they given no training in cultural differances? Religious beliefs??
Top
 
Advertisement
Sponsored Links
 
No. 51
from Gompers
Old May 23, 2004, 07:58 PM

Originally Posted by Kyriaka
Part of the problem here was having no concept of cultural differences. You would never ever approach an Orthodox family about this. The organ people pretty much were asking my family was it ok to mutilate my children (and me). And make money at the same time!

Are they given no training in cultural differances? Religious beliefs??

Just a quick question, as I don't have much experience with the Orthodox religion at all. I understand that some cultures are seriously against organ donation, which they see as mutilation of the body. But what if you needed an organ? Would you not want a transplant? Because I've met plenty of people (who aren't Orthodox) who are totally against donating their own organs upon their death, but admit that they'd definitely want an organ transplant should they need one at some point. And that's not right! Do people of the Orthodox faith accept blood transfusions and donate blood as well? I'm just trying to gain some insight here, so please no flames.
Top
 
No. 52
from Kyriaka
Old May 23, 2004, 08:20 PM

Just a quick question, as I don't have much experience with the Orthodox religion at all. I understand that some cultures are seriously against organ donation, which they see as mutilation of the body. But what if you needed an organ? Would you not want a transplant?
_________________
Not all Orthodox are Greeks so I cant speak for the other cultures.

The only restriction is against the harvesting of the heart. However, there are concerns with organs that are not "double". For us much is a personal issue.

Unlike Roman Catholics, Canon Law for us only applies to salvation. So, of course, this issue doesnt fall under such. Much is personal conviction.

Obvouisly, nurses/staff cannot know what people's personal convictions are but when dealing with a differant culture to step lightly is only showing good manners.

For most, personal beliefs are wound up in mutilation of the body with autopsy issues. I would never have an autopsy or authorize for one to be done. Or cremation.


Because I've met plenty of people (who aren't Orthodox) who are totally against donating their own organs upon their death, but admit that they'd definitely want an organ transplant should they need one at some point. And that's not right!
_______________
It might not be right. However, there is a differance between mutilation of a dead body and operating on a live human being.


Do people of the Orthodox faith accept blood transfusions and donate blood as well? I'm just trying to gain some insight here, so please no flames.[/quote]
____________________
There is no problem with blood transfusions. The only people I know who are against that are Jahovah Witnesses and they would not donate either.
Top
 
No. 53
from Kyriaka
Old May 23, 2004, 08:26 PM

I think most of the problem was that this was seen as money grabbing to my family at the sacrifice of human beings.

And not accepting the answer as NO and just accepting that and not walking away offended them greatly.

My personal belief is that I am very warry of it because the boundary between life and death is so very fuzzy. But also because the official line is that wealthy and famous people are not at an advantage...but I dont believe it. I do think it gives them an advantage over others.
Top
 
No. 54
from NeuroICURN
Old May 23, 2004, 09:20 PM

Originally Posted by Kyriaka
Part of the problem here was having no concept of cultural differences. You would never ever approach an Orthodox family about this. The organ people pretty much were asking my family was it ok to mutilate my children (and me). And make money at the same time!

Are they given no training in cultural differances? Religious beliefs??
Oh yeah, because that's what it's all about....mutilating bodies and making money!

Nevermind the 50 year-old man who was born with a congenital defect of his mesenteric arteries and now needs a cluster transplant....nevermind the 25 year-old woman who just gave birth to twins, now has a rare and lifethreatening form of cardiomyopathy and needs a heart transplant! (Yes, these are two cases that I have been closely associated with.)

It's hypocritical beliefs like that that make me SO angry! You will take, but do not give? (No, I'm not just talking about your personal case anymore.)

And how are we supposed to know your personal beliefs??? I may know that the Jewish faith is listed....but does that mean that you are a practicing Jew? And....what's the harm in asking??? Just because you are Orthodox...does that mean that we should automatically not even ask??? How ridiculous is that? How ridiculous of you to even suggest it!

Now....I will state again, perhaps the person that did it was overzealous, but I cannot give an opinion on that, because I was not there. All the CORE people I have dealt with (and that's a lot) are all very professional, kind and are wonderful in how they deal with the families.

All statements above are my humble opinions! So....don't bother with flaming!

NeuroICURN
Top

2 Readers Gave Kudos
 
No. 55
from Kyriaka
Old May 23, 2004, 10:07 PM

[quote=NeuroICURN]Oh yeah, because that's what it's all about....mutilating bodies and making money!

_____________
I never said that it was all about money. But in MY humble opinion you cannot seperate medicine from business. It is a business. Right or wrong. Good or bad. Money is a part of medicine.
Top
 
No. 56
Old May 23, 2004, 10:10 PM

Of course business is a part of medicine. I think that's a given, but I still can't imagine not giving something of myself or someone I love to help save another human. That's just me of course and to each his own. (though I might hesitate to allow my organs to be donated to someone who wouldn't donate his own now that I think about it)
Top
 
No. 57
from talaxandra
Old May 23, 2004, 11:50 PM

Originally Posted by NeuroICURN
Sounds to me like these cases, if true, then the MDs need a lesson in not only properly declaring brain death, but also on what brain death is. In the case of the person breathing spontaneously.....well that is one of the criteria, the person CAN NOT be breathing spontaneously....if they are, they are NOT brain dead, yet.
As for the third case you cited...you did not say that she was ever declared brain dead....more sounds like they were withdrawing care. Also, one CANNOT be declared brain dead, when there are certain things in the bloodwork that could even just possibly explain them not responding normally.
I'm sorry if I misrepresented the authors' position in this article, or my own - the point was not that these were case where brain-dead patients became "un-brain-dead" (for want of a less clumsy phrase). Rather it is that determinations of brain death are sometimes made when patients don't fit the criteria. In the cited cases, these reasons may have included inevitable somatic death (or perceived inevitable somatic death), a viable recipient in the wings, or perhaps even financial aspects (this last is not explicit in the text).
I agree with you, NeuroICURN, that these cases describe patients who are not brain-dead - that was the point of the article. The reason I posted it is that, if relatives are told that a patient is brain-dead and s/he isn't, or isn't yet, or is brain damaged, then this muddies the waters for everyone. The term 'brain dead' is thrown around a lot, and as we can see from the discussion thus far, informed and interested health professionals are not always any clearer about it than lay people. For example, on my unit (which incorporates neurosciences), staff refer to patients as being 'brain dead' when they mean unconscious, unresponsive or hypoxically brain damaged, although they know that part of the definition of brain death is that the patient is ventilator-dependant.
About the third case: although van Norman does not specify that the patient had been declared brain dead, she does say: "On the day of anticipated organ collection..." and "Vital organ collection was canceled..." These phrases seem to indicate that organ collection was planned, timed, rather than related to withdrawal of treatment. It is possible, of course, that treatment was planned to be withdrawn that day, with post-mortem organ retrieval, which would seem to be premature. However, as the article is specifically about declaring brain death, I think it's safe to presume that the third patient had been declared brain dead like the other two.
Top
 
No. 58
Old May 24, 2004, 05:34 AM

[quote=Kyriaka]
Originally Posted by NeuroICURN
Oh yeah, because that's what it's all about....mutilating bodies and making money!

_____________
I never said that it was all about money. But in MY humble opinion you cannot seperate medicine from business. It is a business. Right or wrong. Good or bad. Money is a part of medicine.
I tend to agree with this to a point, from my personal experience with my son. We took him to Chicago University for his transplant and that is where we stayed for 4 months until he died. I had some altercations with the doctor there but that happens when you know to much about what is going on and dont agree with his care. After he died I had kept in touch with the transplant coordinator and one day I got his bill after my insurance paid. The whole bill was greater then $900,000.00. I called the coordinator having a balance of $70,000.00 for some medications that was $10,000.00 a dose. She returned my call after talking to the transplant MD who was in charge of the whole operation and theri response was...and I quote" Dr _______ says we have made more then enough moeny off of you and Brian so we are going to just erase that balance and we will call it even" My son had not been deard 2 weeks ...and they had made enough money and were going to call it even????? MY son gave his life I hardly call that an even exchange.
So yes....sometmes I too think things like this are a "money racket" but then nothing in life is free and every one is out to make a million$.
Get me off this soap box I feel flames. NOt at you guys but at what happened in Chicago. MOre then enough money my heiney!!!!!
Top

1 Reader Gave Kudos
 
No. 59
from Tweety
Old May 24, 2004, 07:55 AM

Originally Posted by Kyriaka
_____________________
My 7 year old passed away. I have now been single for over 10 years and always new things down the road. Although these things are not easy I can honestly say even at 37 years old that I have learned a great deal:


I never understood the handicapped, until I had a handicapped child.

I never understood what it was like to be heavy until I weighed 280 lbs.

I never understood grief until my children died.

I never understood pain until I was burned 60% in a house fire.

I never understood perseverance until I lost 150 lbs.

I never understood desperation until I was infected with Lyme Disease.

I never understood gratitude until I no longer had to take medication for Lyme.

I never understood trust until I lost my job.

And I never understood my future until I decided to go back to school to be a nurse to work critical care burns.

***
You never know what life will give you.
What a courageous and inspiring story. Life's lessons come from experiencing life. Sometimes you can't experience joy until you learn to cry from the depths of your soul.
Top
 
Page 6 of 23 < 12345 6 7891011 > Last »
Reply




Thread Tools


Who's Online
123 members
1,439 guests
1,562

8

Doctors-in-short-supply-responsibilities-for-nurses-may-expa...

7

Less regular sleep for ICU nurses may lead to errors

14

Nurse sends unused medical supplies to needy nations

23

Premature Births Are Fueling Higher Rates of Infant...

6

MRSA Strain Linked to High Death Rates

21

RI hospital fined $150,000 in 5th wrong-site surgery since...

63

Nursing: One of the 6 Thriving Jobs that are Here to Stay???

89

Dad Fights Hospital to Keep Baby on Life Support

12

A nurse can dream...about awesome nursing

16

California Nursing Situation - CINHC's plan to help New...



7

Why am I doing this, anyway?

0

Nurse Heal Thyself

7

My Papa, why I am the nurse I am today.

15

I made it through

11

An angel's gaze

13

A Sister Never Forgets

16

Ruby's Marbles

29

What Do Operating Room Nurses Do?

14

My Little Old Jedi

16

I love this job......

23

"I hear voices"

17

Preventing FRUTI (Foley Related Urinary Tract Infection) in...

23

Error and Attitude

10

It's Just a Shower

6

Searching for the Purpose





Sponsored Links

Currently Reading This Page: 1 (0 members & 1 guests)

Interested in the hottest topics of the week? Subscribe to the Nurse-zine Newsletter.
Enter email address: