Re: What Defines an Indian?
The Cherokee Nation did not "involuntarily disenroll" African Americans. EVERY TRIBAL MEMBER was able to vote (I even received a ballot, and I'm in California now), and the tribe
overwhelmingly passed a regulation that Cherokee tribal members are required to have Indian blood, as determined by ancestoral membership on the Dawes Rolls and subsequent possession of a CDIB card. Many African Americans,
who posess such cards, remain tribal members. The Eastern Band of Cherokees goes even further by requiring that members have at least 1/4 blood quantum.
There literally are swarms of "fake tribes" popping up all over the country (in addition to people claiming to be American Indian) and so rigid requirements must be adhered to in order for "genuine tribes" to remain "genuine." It only makes sense that members of federally-recognized AI tribes be required to prove AI blood quantum. Members' spouses can't be "adopted" into federally-recognized tribes anymore, so why should anyone else?
As far as the Cherokee tribe gleaning "hundreds of millions" of dollars from their casinos, you might want to check out the tribe's Web site (I assume you don't receive the
Cherokee Phoenix); each and every dollar is accounted for and translates into one thing: Lots of Services for Lots of People.
You can't talk of the federal government "stripping" rights of American Indian tribes on one hand, and then deny a tribe's right to make its own decisions about tribal governance on the other. The Cherokee tribe claims sovereignty,
over the BIA, to establish its own membership criteria.
It all boils down to one thing, which is that you must have Indian
blood to be a member of a federally-recognized Indian
tribe. None of
my family members have ever been disenrolled, nor do I know of any bonafide tribal member (Cherokee or otherwise) that has.
Nursing News