Re: Disturbed Energy Field? Yes or No? Originally Posted by healingtouchRN
Everything has an energy field. It has nothing to do with belief. It just is. Just because someone is embarrased by talking about it doesn't mean it doesn't exist.
Speaking as one of those who have expressed embarassment at the NANDA diagnosis of disturbed energy field, a nay-sayer, if you will: it's not that I'm discomforted by talking about the concept. Rather I feel embarassed as a member of the nursing profession that something so unquantifiable, unmeasurable, as ephemeral as an energy field is included in a list of potential and actual problems, alongside such practical, measurable issues as wound care and pain management.
My discomfort is two-fold. The first is, as I mentioned, that this condition is not measurable or quantifiable, by anyone. Wounds have a cause, can be described, have proven interventions, and progress toward healing can be consistently and objectively evaluated and recorded. Pain can be quantified and described, and interventions (from analgesia to distraction therapy) can be trialled, evaluated and tweaked. Energy fields cannot be measured, visualised or recorded, and any interventions cannot be evaluated.
The second reason is that energy field therapies are still very much in the alternative fringe; while conventional medicine is beginning to investigate and evaluate some other complementary therapies, this falls more into the
homeopathy and shark cartilage for cancer treatment. When other kinds of untested treatments (like experimental medications) are used, patients are informed that this is the case, and they are closely monitored. And there is certainly
controversy around the
validity off energy field therapies, and about the qualifications of some of its proponents, particularly
Caroline Myss, who "claims to hold a Ph.D. in 'intuition and energy medicine', but the degree was granted by Greenwich University, a now-defunct correspondence school that was never accredited to deliver higher education awards by any recognized government accreditation authority." (
Wikipedia)
Just because there are people who aren't embarassed talking about it doesn't mean it does exist.
Nursing News