Forced wearing of nursing cap. - page 12
I'm a senior registered nursing student and our school has a pinning ceremony to mark the completion of our program. Our class contains about 20% men, equal split of black and white in both... Read More
Dec 15, '12Quote from DoGoodThenGoShe says she has to wear the cap or not participate in the ceremony. She wants to participate. This is gender discrimination.Court cases have been all over the place when it comes to complying with Title VII, however it can be said absent some pretty strong reasons gender specific dress codes are asking for a court case.
In the OP's particular instance the school did not make the decision but the students themselves via majority vote. Since the event has not yet occured nor is it entirely clear she would be stopped from attending graduation if she didn't wear the cap, not sure how the OP has been harmed.
Sex-Stereotyping and Dress Codes Under Title VII: Why Courts Can't Get it Right
Fight it, OP, fight it. Do NOT stand down, as so many here on the Board suggest. It's little, it's not important, just graduate, just go along to get along, just take the mark of the Beast. I'm telling you, if it matters enough to you, contact your federal senators and House of Reps and learn which fed office handles gender discrimination.
As another person said earlier, your school likely receives federal monies, therefore, should be subject to all anti-discrimination laws. Never mind that students did the voting - it is the school itself telling you "no cap, no participation".
And yes, it is a great question - would an Orthodox Jewish married woman who wears a wig in mixed company or a covered Muslim woman have to wear the cap? Oh, this complex world of ours!
Just don't lay down and die because some school official said you have to do this or not do that. Fight for your rights.
Dec 17, '12Quote from Guttercat:: patiently ::: No, sex discrimination is based on gender (including, in my opinion, gender identity), not dress. Match point.
But this is not sex discrimination. You are not being denied any of the facilities or opportunities of your educational program based on your gender. A photograph doesn't meet that standard. Care to play again?
Well then by that argument she can show up for the photograph in a cap, and a jockstrap worn on the outside.
Mandating all females wear a cap or they will be excluded, is sex discrimination.
Care to play again?
Dec 17, '12I viewed my cap with the same pride any graduate would of their neat little graduation cap and tassel!
I never viewed it as sexist anymore than I view my brassiere!
Some things are made for women, some things are made for men.
This is just my opinion and I am in no way would I attempt to change anyone else's opinion on the matter.
Funny, but the men in my graduating class actually commented on a wee bit of jealousy that we women wore caps.
Not that they wanted to strut across the stage in a cap, but that they appreciated the tradition.
Holding that cap in my hands for the first time was an amazing feeling. I thought it was beautiful!
It was a symbol for what I had achieved.
But I was lucky, I wanted to wear that cap and our class voted in favor of the cap.
Had they not, then I would have dealt.
Dec 17, '12Quote from Jean Marie46514I transferred into my college from another college program in the fall of my sophomore year, and they had had their capping ceremony at the end of the spring semester. I picked up my hat at the store and suffered no angst over it. My only problem was that I had never, to my knowledge, seen the cap of my new college and didn't know how to put it together. I had no way of knowing that the patch of the college seal on it had been sewn on upside down, so it was a puzzlement until my first clinical day.
It might not be an important issue to you, but, maybe attending the pinning ceremony IS important to the OP, who knows. Attending mine was to me, anyway.
I took my finals a week early because I was moving out of town, but to the best of my knowledge there was no pinning ceremony anyway. I got my pin at the bookstore, and suffered no angst over that either.
And I bow to no one over my passion and commitment to nursing, both professionally and personally. Symbols are great, but those moments pass.
Dec 17, '12Quote from GrnTeaAnd only ONE GENDER is being required to wear the hat.:: patiently ::: No, sex discrimination is based on gender (including, in my opinion, gender identity), not dress. Match point.
Dec 17, '12Not even remotely discriminatory in any way shape or form. They have basically said this is part of your student formal, hell they even gave you the courtesy of letting the students vote on it. If you choose not to wear your complete uniform then you may not participate. Do you think officers are given any choice in what they wear? No, it's a uniform. So basically this falls under first world problems.
Dec 17, '12Quote from woohHere is a photo from Clinton Community College in New York during their pinning ceremony. As you can see, the MALE'S are not wearing caps.And only ONE GENDER is being required to wear the hat.
Ceremonies-Capping and Pinning
A photo of a nursing class from 1899, with two male nurses in attendence. NO CAP.
Nursing History Digitization Project
Here is a photo from "back in the day" of female nurses, all in caps, in the 1950's.
Caps were a FEMALE part of the FEMALE . Just like men wear ties and women wear bra's, again caps are a part of the FEMALE UNIFORM.
People who scream discrimination over something this ridiculous are attention-seeking, IMO.
Dec 17, '12You will only be wearing it for a few hours. Then yin can trash it and likely never have to wear one again! You just graduated nursing school, don't let something so trivial become an issue. Shoot if they told me I could graduate tomorrow, but I had to a cap, I would suck it up and strut in their like the King of England! Lol! Jk! But seriously, don't let that brief moment submission ruin the Bigger Picture you've made it threw nursing school.
The only time the girls in Our program wear the caps is at pinning, and most of then can't wait to wear it because it means they will be finished!
Dec 17, '12Quote from BluegrassRNCouldn't have said it better.The class voted, you lost. Your options are to wear the cap or not participate. Simple.
It's not something to get worked up over. I personally agree with you about the caps, but it's not a sword to die upon, nor is it something to tarnish an otherwise special event. If you want to attend, wear the cap. Keep it for your next naughty nurse / zombie nurse/ nurse Ratchet Halloween costume. I you can't bring yourself to wear the cap, skip the ceremony. Your accomplishments are independent of any ceremony.