Forced wearing of nursing cap. - page 14
by onetiredstudent 22,692 Views | 253 Comments
I'm a senior registered nursing student and our school has a pinning ceremony to mark the completion of our program. Our class contains about 20% men, equal split of black and white in both genders. I am approaching 50 and... Read More
- 3Dec 14, '12 by woohI don't know why OP is complaining. Women used to not be able to vote. Sheesh, she should just be glad that women can vote. And make 77 cents for every dollar her male classmates will make. Women used to only 70 cents on the dollar (50 cents on the dollar, 30 cents on the dollar...)
You do have to pick your battles. For a lot of people, this may not be a battle you would pick. But just because this isn't a battle YOU would pick, doesn't make it any less discrimination. Different rules for different genders IS discrimination.
How about this, only black students have to wear a hat? Discrimination?
- 3Dec 14, '12 by BrandonLPNQuote from Conqueror+Well, just because some people "hold it dear" doesn't meanTo clarify there is a BIG difference between simply disagreeing with or "not getting" a tradition that some hold dear and calling it every degrading name that you can think of.
they should be able to force it on the OP.
And, let's be honest. In no way is this any sort of "sacred tradition" for the classmates who voted for the cap. For crying out loud, they are new grads. They have never been nurses. How can they have any traditions?
I "get it". This has nothing to do with the classmates' traditions being violated. They are throwing a hissy fit because the OP not wearing a cap might spoil their pretty pretty princess group photo moment.
- 1Dec 14, '12 by jadelpn GuideQuote from psu_213The spirit of the post suggests that the OP could be either transgender, identifies with an alternate gender, or has a belief system that should give right to not wear what is a classically female dress.Where is this coming from?? This debate has nothing do being transgender, which is a totally different discussion.
Therefore, seeing as students should have rights as adults, even if one finds a nursing cap demeaning to women, there should be a choice. And I think nursing needs to get away with what are classic roles/unrelenting rules within the occupation--you can be the least strong nurse, but put a cap on and wa-la you are nurse extrodinare? It is putting far too much meaning on an article of clothing that a large majority of nurses don't/can't wear in their practice. (and I do know their's a number of nurses who do/can/required to). So it is ultimately not a reflection of anything other than a female role in nursing. And that there's no thought for males to wear headgear, then it becomes discrimitory. And the OP paid for nursing school, succeeded, and now not choosing to participate in one small part of a ceremony that because of a personal reason (and honestly, it is not our business the specifics) one is told "stay home". Inappropriate.
It would be interesting if a female were a firefighter or a police officer upon academy graduation insists on wearing a skirt and heels instead of pants, and was told that she couldn't come to graduation unless she put on the cargos and boots. But because she identifies with the fact that she is a female in a male dominated profession, she would like to look feminine. Skirts and heels are not something that a female firefighter would wear on the job. She has strong feelings about retaining her femininity on this occasion. Should she have to stay home?
The OP has strong feelings that suggest that she not identify with classic female roles. A college that she has paid to attend should not have a say in a ceremony that she is entitled to attend.
- 2Dec 14, '12 by Esme12 Senior ModeratorQuote from BrandonLPNTherein lies the problem.....I'll say it again. If we clung to every tradition, we'd all be walking around looking pretty ridiculous. Time passes. Things change. Traditions die.
You have to know where you have been to clearly see where you are going.
- 3Dec 14, '12 by elkparkI never hear anyone complaining about the gowns and mortarboards at graduation -- that's old-fashioned! Nobody dresses lke that anymore! It's a stupid, meaningless tradition! People should be able to wear whatever they feel like wearing to Commencement!
This is the same thing. It's an official school function. Get over it.
- 5Dec 14, '12 by woohQuote from elkparkThe difference being EVERYONE wears the gown and mortarboards. It's not dependent upon whether your crotch is an innie or an outie.I never hear anyone complaining about the gowns and mortarboards at graduation
- 4Dec 14, '12 by x_factorBack in the "white hat" days of nursing, almost all nurses were FEMALE. The FEMALE nurses wore the white hats as a part of their FEMALE nursing uniform. So I don't see the discrimination in acknowledging a tradition in which includes a specific addition to a FEMALE nurse's uniform, by requiring the FEMALES to wear the white hats.
People these day's are just so quick to scream discrimination.