Question about peer review

So I am going to peer review! Yeah! I don't really want to go into specifics for obvious reasons. So I know that some of you out there on this board have served on peer review boards before. Here is my question.... What kind of things do you want to hear from a nurse to persuade you not to make a board report? I have lots of things on my side right now i.e. unsafe staffing, over AWHONN standards, letters of support from the MD, documentation of other nurses doing the same thing (my defense is that this is a system error not a ME error), reasons why I am not at risk for this infraction again, how I admitted my error instead of covering it up (which I could have easily done) ect Do peer review people want to hear remorse, excuses, suggestions on how to fix the issue. I am basically guilty of a documentation error. If anyone might have some detailed advice to offer I would be happy to PM more info. Just seeking advice.