organ donation, political issue bleh

Nurses General Nursing

Published

Ya know I've kinda always been known as a nice polite respectful young thing , go with the flow kinda gal but something that was said to me a little while ago really rubbed me the wrong way.

We were discussing organ donation at work , and I was talking about how I think its crazy for organs to go to waste and a little about how its terrible that so many people die while waiting on a the transplant list etc etc when someone suggested that organ donation seemed to be a political cause of mine and that I should respect the fact that some people just find it apphaling to donate a loved ones organs and that a person should be "buried whole and complete".

I respect everyones right to an opinion on any and every topic, firm believer in the fact that we can really all agree to disagree on some things, but this person made it seem to all around that I was pimping some big political agenda and couldnt see the other side of the story.

what I wanted to say to her but didnt ,and what I will share with you my trusted friends is that my "political cause" has a name, Rena.

Growing up the person I felt closest too was always my aunt Rena, she lived half an hour away yet her home seemed like home to me. We would always joke that I was meant to be her daughter because we were so much alike. I picked up on many Rena'isms growing up, some great like my ability to see the good in most everyone, some not so great, like the fact I wear my heart on my sleeve and get taken advantage of many times. Rena, my moms oldest sister was the person I admired most in my life, gave me my first haircut - thus starting the infamous "wendy looks like a little boy with a dress on" photo collection, she held my hand when I got my ear pierced - yep I said ear, I was such a wimp that I could only stand one ear to be done!, when my parents were caught up in the swirling events of my fathers affair and the breakdown of their marriage my aunt Rena got this life of mine back on track. It wasnt easy being 12 and having your world fall apart before your eyes, it was made much easier by knowing that there was at least one person on this planet who was there for you, regardless of time or circumstance.

My mom lost her sister Mary in 1995, she got extremely ill and to this day we dont know exactly what caused her death, but Mary being the nurse she was probably realized that she was very sick and did not want to live the way she saw many of her patients live and die. Mary was 54 when she died. My aunt Rena was the one to snap us all out of the sadness we were feeling, the life of the party. She started feeling ill herself and finally after much prompting by all of her friends and her family she went to the doctor. I only wish I was a nurse with some medical knowledge back then because surely I could have seen some signs or symptoms of what turned out to be advance stage liver disease. People assumed left right and center that my aunt Rena was a drinker, far from it , she was married to an alcoholic for years and never had a drop to drink.... the doctors agreed that she had many congenital liver problems and would need a transplant. She accepted this , refused to get down about it and life pretty much carried on. Until one day she got so sick she would have to be flown to a regional transplant center and spend the rest of her wait there.

by this time I was graduating highschool, falling in love for the first time , trying to figure out what to do with my life and worried sick about my aunt Rena. We didnt live in the same city as the regional transplant center so we made frequent trips each time they thought they had a liver, and then it would go to someone sicker, or wasnt suitable etc. One time my aunt even got to the OR and then was returned because the organ wasnt suitable, she woke up thinking she had her transplant already. then on mothers day 1996 we got word that there was a liver on the way for her, the roller coaster of emotions just boiled over.....so excited happy scared nervous, I went to her early that morning and told her all the things I was feeling and that she was gonna be just fine! 8 and a half hours later they let me in the recovery room to see her, the Dr said that we were lucky cuz she was on borrowed time with that liver of hers....recovery wise she had setbacks , wasnt breathing great, not maintaining sats, infections etc so she had to be trached - this happened on her 56th birthday. All in all the road was extremely hard,but not unbearable, until we learned that the anti rejection drugs had fostered the growth of an inoperable brain tumour , she died in september at 56 years old , my mom lost both her sisters within 1 calendar year and I lost my number one fan,biggest supporter and the person who understood me the most.

til the day she died her liver worked wonderfully...she could have lived from that transplant, I am forever in debt to the family who made that tough decision , although it didnt work out, the choice to donate that liver mattered to people, it mattered to me and it mattered to my aunt.

hearing someone trivilize all I went through by calling it a political cause just got to me

sorry for rambling

you really would have loved my aunt Rena guys..

there are few people in this world that you could listen to forver , turn to for support, who make you smile just by being around and who care about everyone they encounter, she was one of these people.

its not a political cause to me, its personal.

Good thread Wendy

Believe in donation - it is a personal issue - but very important - l as l said in another thread - l was so proud of a friend of mine who has just donated one of her kidneys to someone - l think that is an amazing gift.

Dont' forget Bone Marrow!! :cool:

Save a life with just some discomfort in the hip region and 23 hours in a hospital. You even get cool drugs and a nice nap, all billed directly to someone elses insurance! Where can you get a better deal?

http://www.bonemarrow.org

thanks chemorn for reminding us about the bone marrow donation!! we don't have to die to give of our bone marrow and we can live on knowing what a wonderful thing we've done when we are able to match with someone in need! :D

i had a cousin who died of breast cancer while she was in the preparation period for a bone marrow transplant. she left 3 beautiful children (2, 5 & 7 years old) and a loving husband who all miss her terribly. our entire family still feels the loss after 7 years.

on a lighter note, i've told everyone who knows me that if they don't donate my organs (if anyone can use them) that i'm definately going to haunt them for the rest of their lives!!! i'll rattle chains and make creepy sounds every night to remind them that they didn't respect my wishes!:rotfl:

My dearly loved grandad - who was my best friend in the whole world - died suddenly of a massive heart attack when I was 14. His corneas were donated and while I don't remember if any other organs were taken (he was in his sixties) I remember my mom getting a letter from the Canadian Institute for the Blind thanking her for the donation and that because of his "gift, two people can see". My mom cried for days..what a lovely legacy to leave.

Ten years later my boyfriends parents (who were Jehovah's Witnesses) told me my Grandad was going to hell for that. I was so ANGRY. My rage is still there, to this day.

I dumped the boyfriend.

Originally posted by hapeewendy

We were discussing organ donation at work , and I was talking about how I think its crazy for organs to go to waste and a little about how its terrible that so many people die while waiting on a the transplant list etc etc when someone suggested that organ donation seemed to be a political cause of mine and that I should respect the fact that some people just find it apphaling to donate a loved ones organs and that a person should be "buried whole and complete".

i think that it is amazing that people expect you to respect their views and opinions while they blatanly show no respect for yours. :rolleyes:

I also have the little red heart on my drivers license. I am a very strong supporter of organ donation and cannot understand why anyone would object to it. But, while I don't understand, I do respect the opinions of those who feel differently. Having said that, have you ever noticed that, while some folks want to enter the afterlife with all their organs, if THEY require an organ transplant to stay in THIS life a little while longer, they suddenly change their tune. Sending someone else to the afterlife without a heart or minus a kidney doesn't seem to concern them too much.

I have kind of a radical solution. Please tell me what you think. Form a registry for organ donors. In order to get on the registry, you must sign a legal document donating your organs, and the approval of your loved one's is not required. Once signed up, you're good to go. OK...here is the radical part. ONLY registered organ donors are eligible to recieve organ transplants. If you "don't believe in organ donation," that is certainly your right. We will do everything we can to make you comfortable during your transition to the afterlife. But don't expect to recieve an organ if you weren't willing to donate one.

Whenever I have presented this idea to others, I have gotten reactions that range from "That makes so much sense" to "What are you, some kind of monster?" I'd be very interested in what you folks think.

Originally posted by sunnygirl272

ok..i think i have asked this question on this board before....

i am not allowed to donate blood...because i have IBD..(inflammoatory bowel disease, not to be confused with IBS, irritable bowel syndrome) anyway...the rationale being that they don't know conclusively what causes IBD...many possibilities, many theories...soooo...would this bear on my ability to be organ donor?

always have other more important things to discuss with my gastroenterologist when i am at my 6month followups..

I also cannot usually give blood, because I am almost always just shy of enough iron for their requirements....but it doesn't mean that I cannot keep on trying to give

know i am not the endall on this subject, but do know i am an organ donor, etc..........

once i am gone from this body, i do not need any of it anymore, but life goes on.....

and if not for an actual donation of an organ such as a liver, etc.....

there is always skin and tissue for grafts, etc.

and then there is always the option of donating your body for scientific research.......

or even for nursing/medical students to use in their education...................

there is always a use for what we have...........

I am also a registered organ donor (if they are still any good when I'm done with them :) ) In my state, the words Organ Donor are in the right lower corner of everyone's license, and the letter Y or N indicates the persons prefrerence. I agree that the deceased has no further use for them, and "Heaven knows they are needed here."

Wendy, I am so sorry that your sweet aunt Rena passed away despite the organ transplant. I had an aunt Renah also, only with a h at the end of her name. I don't know why your co-workers felt that you had to have an agena because you feel so strongly about organ donations. It is an invaluable program that saves lives and improves the quality of life of people everyday. Some people are negative about almost any topic or look for agendas even when there aren't any.

I hope that your holiday was pleasant and restful. I also hope that you were able to find some time to think about your work options and your direction in nursing. I know that you were feeling stressed before your holiday. As my old military unit motto stated "Keep Up The Fire!"

Chuck

Specializes in Critical Care.

Wendee,

How lucky you were to have such a wonderful woman to turn to, some people never have that. I am so sorry for your loss, both of my parents are gone now and I think about them every day. Of course it is personal for you and why shouldn't it be. Some people just have to say something rotten because they don't know the pure unconditional love and trust that you and your Aunt had. At least you have good memories to hold dear to you, what does that mean nurse have? Probably nothing.

+ Add a Comment