Which job would you take?

So if you were looking at two job offers and...

Job #1) Offered the perfect position, the duties are exactly what you have been looking for BUT the environment is a concern... staff doesn't always get along, a consultant team has come in to help everyone "communicate better," the docs can be arrogant etc...

while,

Job #2) Offered the perfect environment, everyone is friendly and helpful, docs are sane, things are organized, etc.. etc.. but the position is not exactly what you wanted, it's close, but it contains some duties you were hoping to avoid. Those duties are infrequent, but will be stress inducing all the same.

What would you choose? The position with the ideal environment or the position with the ideal duties/responsibilites?

No, waiting for a job that contains the best of both worlds is not an option.