True Afib will NEVER have a true, distinctive p wave b/c the atria is FIBRILLATING, not contracting. So in Atrial Fibrillation with frequent/occasional Premature Atrial Contractions, look for distinct p waves to tell which are true PAC's.
I won't presume to speak for Tweety, but I think this is where the confusion comes from. My interpretation is as follows: As you state, with true afib, you have no distinctive p waves- the distinct electrical representation of a single focus discharge. But unless the hr is 60 or below and you're running on a junctional or ventricular pacer, the discharges in the atria are present- they just occur as multi-focal discharges. As such, this ectopy can occur anywhere (and everywhere

) in the atria. With no regularity, it can't truly be a pac. In my mind, the only way I could note pac's on strip containing afib is if the heart is extremely irritable and you have brief flops from fib to sinus and back again. In that case, I could see a regular pattern, if even only for 6-10 beats and witness a pac within that stretch.
That's my thinking... where are my holes?