Indy,
I feel your pain about the Birkie's. I love the styles and the arch is good, but my heel absolutly kills me after about 3 hours in them.
It makes my heel feel like it's walking on cement after a while. I tend then to "grip" with my toes way too much to compensate for the discomfort and then my shin(s) start to hurt.
I lurve my Dansko's and I agree about the lateral roll. If your lateral roll is that bad than the Dansko rep I talked with actually recommended that you see someone about orthopedic insoles.
Lateral rolling is common to most people, but if it's wearing out the 1 1/2 inch sole on a Dansko quickly and making ankles turn then it might be time to see someone.
I've noticed that over the years as a nurse, my feet have gotten bigger, flatter and the arches are slowly falling.
I own five pair of Dansko's. I rotate my shoes everyday so that they all get even wear. I'm going on 5 years with the same 5 pairs and it has helped the lateral wear on the shoe.
I saw a Dansko rep in a shoe store the other day and they were very helpful.
I'm wondering if all of us with the lateral problem write to Dansko and/or Sanita, if they might look into a solution?
www.dansko.com
www.sanitaclogs.com