I have not had expereince with the dressing you are talking about but have had good expereince with hyperfix/fixomull on 1st degree burns. Personal experience when on hot day ironing in the ER... anyway ended up with iron burn on stomach (don't ask) and applied hyperfix with ice. Pain gone in short time - left hyperfix until it peeled off naturally (you can remove it with either eucalyptus oil or tea-tree oil) and lo and behold all better!!!