From an Anesthetist's Perspective
OK, I'm sure to get flamed for this, but here goes. I know how tough you ED nurses are, I used to be one.
Yes, etomidate is a great drug. It has very good hypnotic properties, and as a general rule does not cause the hypotension and bradycardia some other induction agents can cause. It is ultra short acting, and can be very useful in the hands of someone familiar with it, and all the effects it can cause. HOWEVER, it is not without risks. There is a great potential to cause harm to a patient.
I know ER docs hate hearing this, but anesthetic agents should never be given by anyone not familiar with them, and by familiar I mean with anesthesia training and experience. Why? Because of the risks associated with all anesthetic agents. Lets look for a minute at this drug so many of you are so fond of.
Most anesthesia providers rarely, if ever, use etomidate. Many of the advantages you all see with it can be achieved through other drugs, with less side effects.
While it generally does not cause the hypotension that can be caused by propofol, for example, it can do so. Therefore, I wouldn't give it without having neosynepherine, ephedrine, and atropine all drawn up and also ready to give. The same holds true for apnea. Generally, etomidate won't cause this, but it can. Therefore, you need to have intubating materials at hand. At hand, not know where they are.
Etomidate also has a nasty reputation among those who have used it for inducing post anesthesia vomiting. Nasty enough that many of us know the drug as "vomidate." This effect is magnified when it is given in combination with a narcotic. Considering the fact that the only worse thing that can happen to a patient's lungs than aspiration of stomach contents is a shotgun blast to the chest, what are you going to do if your patient starts vomiting before his/her airway reflexes come back? I never extubate a patient induced with etomidate until they are awake and have intact reflexes. And I don't use etomidate as a sedation agent, the risks are too great.
Speaking of fentany, one of you mentioned that is a favored drug in your ED. Its a good drug, but did you know that you can induce chest wall rigidity so strongly with fentanyl that you will be unable to bag the patient? Better have sux at hand to treat this, and if you are going to give sux, better have intubation stuff at hand as well.
Literature lists the dose of induction of anesthesia for etomidate at 0.3 mg/kg. One of you said you find 20-30 mg to be a good dose to use in the ED. That's an induction dose for general anesthesia for most patients (66 to 100 kg patients). So, consider that when you administer that dose of etomidate, you are inducing general anesthesia.
Our ED where I now work does all these things as well, but they call for me or my partner to administer the medications and monitor the patients during the procedure. Not because we don't trust our ED nurses, we do. But because we don't think its right to force ED nurses to do the job we are uniquely trained, experienced and equipped to do.
Goodman and Gilmans
The Pharmacological Basis of Therapeutics is one of the gold standard textbooks for teaching pharmacology. See if your hospital library has it, and look up some of the drugs you are giving. You might be surprised at the risks you are taking.
Kevin McHugh, CRNA
Nursing News