I would like to hear form those that have refused the mandatory Flu Shot. - page 3

I don't want to turn this in to a debate regarding the flu shot. I have made my opinion and until some more evidence based studies are performed I don't want to get it. Up until now I have been... Read More

  1. Visit  Steve123 profile page
    0
    10 years ago I heard that flu kills 36,000 people every year. If you remember it was shortage of vaccine 10 years ago. There is no shortage now, more people get vaccinated, but you still hear that 36,000 people dies of flu. What is your conclusion? My collusion is: flu shot is not effective,
  2. Get the hottest topics every week!

    Subscribe to our free Nursing Insights newsletter.

  3. Visit  Steve123 profile page
    0
    You think flu shot is safe if take it as recommended? They recommend flu shot every year beginning from the age of 6 months old and until you die. It is a new recommendation. It translates into 70-80+ flu shots in life time. Experts say it is safe. But how can they know? Only 80 years from now, when dr able to assess people who get it annually from their birth until death, you will be able to say it is safe to take it as recommended. At this time I refuse flu shot, prefer to ware mask.
  4. Visit  macawake profile page
    1
    Quote from Steve123
    10 years ago I heard that flu kills 36,000 people every year. If you remember it was shortage of vaccine 10 years ago. There is no shortage now, more people get vaccinated, but you still hear that 36,000 people dies of flu. What is your conclusion? My collusion is: flu shot is not effective,
    Even if by some coincidence the number of deaths were exactly 36.000 this year and the same ten years ago that would mean a lower percentage of deaths since the population today is larger than it was then.

    However, the number 36.000 is an estimate based on a statistical model. Furthermore it's an average for nine flu seasons during the 1990s. The range of estimated annual influenza-related deaths during that time period was 17.000-52.000. Nobody knows the exact number of deaths caused by influenza, the reasons for this are explained by the CDC. The CDC explain it much better than I do, so I've included the link.

    CDC - Seasonal Influenza (Flu) - Questions and Answers Regarding Estimating Deaths from Influenza in the United States

    In order to determine if a vaccine or any type of intervention/treatment is effective you need much more information and data than just the number of deaths from two different years (even if they actually had been exactly 36.000 each year). For example, some strains of the of the influenza virus are associated with higher numbers of death than others.
    I simply don't think that you have presented enough information to support the conclusion you're drawing.

    Based on research, there is no doubt in my mind that the flu vaccine saves lives.
    Last edit by macawake on Feb 26, '13
    elkpark likes this.
  5. Visit  pmabraham profile page
    0
  6. Visit  imjustme123 profile page
    0
    Quote from pmabraham
    Please post a synopsis of this article for those of us who do not have an account with medscape. Thank you!

    (moderator edit to add - Medscape is a free sign up service and you will be able to click on and read entire article)
    Last edit by sirI on Mar 6, '13


Nursing Jobs in every specialty and state. Visit today and Create Job Alerts, Manage Your Resume, and Apply for Jobs.

Top