4,000 Nurses strike for patient care.

Nurses Union

Published

4,000 brave women and men, RNs from the California Nurses Association/National Nurses Organizing Committee, are spending this week on the picket lines outside of Sutter Health Hospitals throughout Northern California, on a 10-day strike over patient care issues. This is an important strike for a re-energized American labor movement and a key moment for the nation's battle for quality healthcare.

This is a long strike for any worker, but one that turns on the most basic issues of nursing and patient safety. Sutter Health is, even by HMO standards, an outlier in their push to cut corners on patient care in order to bump up corporate profits. You can't argue with their success on either count. In 2006, Sutter reported record profits of $587 million. Much of those profits come from routinely understaffing their hospital units by denying meal and rest breaks to nurses. As a practical matter, what this means is that if a nurse, in the midst of a 12-hour shift, decides to take her lunch break...then her patients lose coverage.

Hasn't every nurse faced that ethical dilemma? Grab a sandwich or make sure my sick patients are cared for? Especially for nurses, who define our work as "patient advocacy?" And, under California's landmark staffing law, it's no longer legal.

That's why these nurses had to walk out and make a personal sacrifice for the good of their patients and their profession.

Sutter's response? To embark on a campaign of harassment, intimidation, and lies. Sutter has threatened to fire strikers, cut off health benefits, has posted guards at nursing stations to glare at RNs, and has taken to regularly demonizing its own nurses in the press.

The good news? Sutter foolishly picked a fight with a group of (mostly) women who are not easily intimidated...especially by some corporate hack who have shown they don't care about patient care.

The better news? This strike affirms the relevance of America's labor movement to the key questions our country is undergoing. This strike has been marked by deep public support and sympathy, with Sutter Health's behavior roundly criticized by elected officials, the public, and the news media. High-profile strikes like this that win over the public make it easier for other groups of workers to stand up for their own rights. It's worth noting that the recent increase in the numbers of unionized workers has largely come from the ranks of healthcare workers--and that CNA/NNOC is the nation's fastest-growing union.

And the best news? The nurses of Sutter Health are demonstrating the way forward in our country's struggle for guaranteed healthcare. A major reason our health system is so dysfunctional is that corporations like Sutter Health have rigged the system and treat patients as profit-makers, not as human beings. If we can win patient safety advances at Sutter, we can win them across the country--especially if we inspire the nation's nurses to continue taking their patient advocacy from the bedside to the statehouse and even to the streets.

If these nurses inspire you, why not call the CEO of Sutter, Pat Fry at 916 286 6752 and tell him it's time to settle with the nurses!

For more on the Sutter fight and ongoing news, go to: www.calnurses.org

Specializes in Neurosciences.

Wrong post.

Google links aren't answers to my questions, herring RN. If you had any firsthand knowledge of the Sutter situation you wouldn't need to do a Google search. You could simply share your experience.

Either you're a Sutter nurse who went out on strike or you're not.

If you're a Sutter nurse who went out on strike please tell me how the strike turned out for you--what did you gain; what did you lose; do you have a contract now; if you don't have a contract are you close to getting one?

If you're not a Sutter nurse who participated in the Sutter strike then you're not someone who can answer my questions.

Specializes in Critical care, tele, Medical-Surgical.
Google links aren't answers to my questions, herring RN. If you had any firsthand knowledge of the Sutter situation you wouldn't need to do a Google search. You could simply share your experience.

Either you're a Sutter nurse who went out on strike or you're not.

If you're a Sutter nurse who went out on strike please tell me how the strike turned out for you--what did you gain; what did you lose; do you have a contract now; if you don't have a contract are you close to getting one?

If you're not a Sutter nurse who participated in the Sutter strike then you're not someone who can answer my questions.

I am sorry.

Are you a nurse?

Are you a nurse?

Yes I am.

Specializes in Critical care, tele, Medical-Surgical.
Yes I am.

Thank you nurse!

I asked because the terma of service require members to only use nurse, LPN, RN and such in user name if they hold that license.

But many don't include it.

I was hoping some of the Sutter nurses statements in the videos could help a bit.

Colfax,

The bottom line is that it is not dishonest to share information about strikes that are gained from participation in local business meetings. Organizers quite often have an intimate awareness about the causes of a walkout through their work in the union.

Herring answered your questions respectfully with sourceable and accessible links to answer your questions.

If you want to have a discussion about issues I think you will get farther in expressing your viewpoint by being respectful. My take is that you were trying to pick a fight with posters who were trying to answer your questions with information that you could evaluate.

Or do you only compose long, detailed, slanderous threads about the deplorable working conditions at places where you've never worked?
This quote verges on namecalling which just isn't cricket on a bulletin board dedicated to respectful open debate between professionals. I encourage you to think carefully about how you phrase your responses in the future.

HM2Viking,

I apologize for my harsh tone. The Sutter strike evokes strong feelings on both sides. I'll take a timeout from this thread and maybe we'll have a calmer discussion of these issues in the future.

Colfax

Specializes in mostly in the basement.

Either you're a Sutter nurse who went out on strike or you're not.

If you're a Sutter nurse who went out on strike please tell me how the strike turned out for you--what did you gain; what did you lose; do you have a contract now; if you don't have a contract are you close to getting one?

If you're not a Sutter nurse who participated in the Sutter strike then you're not someone who can answer my questions.

Hi,

Ex-Sutter here---participated in first strike before leaving(resignation btw, so no sour grape'n here).I'll try to be as brief and non-inflammatory as possible.

First, because we are such a well represented and therefore well compensated union facility, in truth as sad as it is to say, most of us viewed the time off, frankly, as a nice small vacation. I know I needed a break.....

What did I gain? A much greater understanding of how little my former employer(and undoubtedly so many others) thinks of my skills and my profession and just what exactly it is we bring to the institution and its ability to provide great care. How interchangeably we are viewed and how hysterical it is to watch 'professionals' resort to intimidation games and threats in order to avert a legally provided for strike action.

Lost? Well, I definitely lost repect for the Nursing Director who was dumb enough to allow a memo she wrote instructing our NM's to "target" specific employees(not for any actual wrongdoing, mind you, just those who may not drink the kool-aid so to speak. I believe she stated it as "you all know who they are") and then harass and belittle them until they quit or with enough scruting could be fired for making some kind of error under the pressure.

Keep in mind, I didn't lose respect for the memo part---I expected such from a person such as herself. The respect went out the window when I realized she wasn't just a malignant individual but incredibly stupid to boot!

Can't speak for the rest....I don't think the contracts are all settled now. I do know many, many employees have left. There have been some gains as far as retirement and pensions, $$$, etc. But you know what? We already know we're well compensated for this high priced CA living. They need to budge on the stuff that matters to us and our patients. Safe staffing always, adequate equipment and lift policies and providing the resources we need in order to provide care that would then have no bounds.

Gee, adequate 'stuff'=happy employees=better JCAHO and PG! Who knew?

Guess not them....

Anyway, that was my experience--can't speak for any others....except see below:

Specializes in mostly in the basement.

You wrote:

Scroll up to your first post in this thread and look again at some things you wrote:

very serious patient care problems endemic to the chain

Sutter Health is, even by HMO standards, an outlier in their push to cut corners on patient care

Much of those profits come from routinely understaffing their hospital units by denying meal and rest breaks to nurses.

Sutter has threatened to fire strikers, cut off health benefits, has posted guards at nursing stations to glare at RNs,

How would you know these things about Sutter if you don't work at Sutter yourself?

I can only tell you that, with these specific statements at least, all are absolutely and undeniably accurate. Where I worked for certain...

I left my Sutter facility because it was getting dangerous, frankly. For patients assuredly but selfishly for my license as well.

Specializes in Critical care, tele, Medical-Surgical.

nurses union reaches deal with mills-peninsula

the california nurses association monday said it has reached a tentative agreement on a contract with mills-peninsula health services, a sutter health affiliate, after 15 months of negotiations during which three brief strikes were called....

http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2008/08/18/bu1312d8qq.dtl

Specializes in ICU/CCU/TRAUMA/ECMO/BURN/PACU/.
nurses union reaches deal with mills-peninsula

the california nurses association monday said it has reached a tentative agreement on a contract with mills-peninsula health services, a sutter health affiliate, after 15 months of negotiations during which three brief strikes were called....

http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2008/08/18/bu1312d8qq.dtl

thank you for sharing this wonderful news. education, mobilization, and collective action, in unity, to win better working conditions, will help this sutter facility attract and retain more nurses to provide the safe care patients deserve. the nurses who work at mills-peninsula are to be commended for their advocacy on behalf of their profession and their patients.

they've fought the good fight, and won. :up:

+ Add a Comment