Study: 100 patients a day in USA wake up during surgery

Specialties CRNA

Published

Just saw the following article in USA Today. Has any of the experienced CRNA's ever experienced this?

Study: 100 patients a day in USA wake up during surgery

By Robert Davis, USA TODAY

Anesthesia failure that allows a patient to wake up during surgery, paralyzed and unable to cry for help, occurs 100 times a day in the USA, a study reports Monday.

The rate is similar to those documented by previous international studies, but many doctors have long questioned the prevalence. This is the first time in more than 30 years that the problem has been quantified in U.S. hospitals.

These findings, and the results of two similar trials also to be released today, led the Food and Drug Administration late Friday to broaden its approval of a device it says has reduced the risk of patients waking up during surgery. The BIS monitor, which is used in one-third of U.S. hospitals, turns the brain's EEG waves into a number that can tell anesthesiologists at a glance how deeply a patient is sedated.

Another study of 1,200 patients found that using the BIS monitor reduced the frequency of surgical awareness by 82%.

Such study results are viewed as preliminary. "Awareness is clearly a problem," says Jeffrey Apfelbaum, professor and chairman of anesthesia and critical care medicine at the University of Chicago. "But these studies have not been vetted through the peer-reviewed process. We are all anxious to find a way to minimize the incidence of this problem, but we need to do it through sound science."

The makers of the monitor, Aspect Medical Systems of Newton, Mass., financed the studies, which are being presented at the annual meeting of the American Society of Anesthesiologists in San Francisco. BIS stands for bispectral index technology.

Anesthesiologists have led the medical profession in patient safety efforts. But many of them have resisted the use of BIS monitors, saying they do not need help determining whether their patients were adequately sedated. "They have their head in the sand," says the study's lead investigator, Peter Sebel, a professor of anesthesiology at Emory University School of Medicine. "They say they have never had a case in their career. I think they may have, they just don't know about it."

His study of nearly 20,000 surgical patients found that for every 1,000 who receive general anesthesia, 1 to 2 people become aware of what is happening to them. Half of them feel pain.

"I did not feel cutting, but I felt tremendous pulling," says Carol Weihrer, who awoke during eye-removal surgery. "It takes a lot of torque to get an eye out."

Since her 45-minute ordeal in 1998, during which she felt surgical tools on her chest, listened to the music played in the surgical suite and felt like gagging because of the tube down her throat, she has become a patient advocate.

"It has been described as worse than rape or kidnapping in that you can't squirm or scream," she says. "There is no way to release your fear or your frustration." She and other patient advocates say patients should ask for a BIS monitor.

My mom woke up like 3 times during her total knee. First time she said "Oh, are you done?" and four masked faces appeared in her line of sight. Someone said "I'll get her" and off she went back to sleep. Second time, she woke up and felt her body being jolted as the surgeon hammered into her femur. She didn't say anything, and thought to herself "oh, they're not done" and closed her eyes again. Third time, I think she said something like they were just finishing up, closing...

She was never scared or in pain, just mostly amused at the whole thing. Does this happen often? Has anyone seen this?

Did your mother have a spinal anesthestic or a general anesthetic? Most times, with a general anesthetic for a TKR, the patient is intubated and cannot speak if they wake up. So she probably wouldn't have been able to make herself heard the first time. With a spinal anesthetic, we routinely sedate a patient and from time to time, the sedation gets light and the patient "wakes up." This is not the same thing as true "recall or waking" from a general anesthetic, actually, it's generally expected to happen. I generally tell my patients that they may hear things from time to time but that I'll get them sleepier if they want it.

I'm glad your mom didn't have pain and wasn't frightened.

Specializes in CRNA, Finally retired.
My mom woke up like 3 times during her total knee. First time she said "Oh, are you done?" and four masked faces appeared in her line of sight. Someone said "I'll get her" and off she went back to sleep. Second time, she woke up and felt her body being jolted as the surgeon hammered into her femur. She didn't say anything, and thought to herself "oh, they're not done" and closed her eyes again. Third time, I think she said something like they were just finishing up, closing...

She was never scared or in pain, just mostly amused at the whole thing. Does this happen often? Has anyone seen this?

1. She had a spinal. If she didn't she would have experienced terrible pain.

2. She had plenty of sedatives on board so she was in a pleasant state.

3. Sounds like a good anesthetic.

Specializes in MICU & SICU.

Even though BIS may not be essential don't you think that at least having it and documenting your readings will help you if you were ever to have a patient contest that they were awake?

Even though BIS may not be essential don't you think that at least having it and documenting your readings will help you if you were ever to have a patient contest that they were awake?

BIS is not worth much in general, but not indicated by any stretch of the imagination for a spinal or epidural.

Nothing personal, but this is the problem with people who have heard of BIS, usually through sensationalistic news articles, and have no idea of what it does or doesn't do. BIS is a device in search of an indication. They've tried for years to market it as an awareness monitor (questionable voodoo science at best). That didn't work despite the garbage research by the bought-and-paid for researchers. They've tried using it as a way to wake patients up more quickly at the end of the case, something that most of us have no problem with to begin with. The latest is using it as a way to save money by using less anesthetic agents and drugs, despite the fact that these represent a very small percentage of an overall hospital bill to begin with.

If BIS was used on every patient, it would add millions of dollars to already strained health care resources - that for a monitor with questionable usefullness at best.

When there is clear and convincing evidence that BIS is beneficial, you'll see it in mainstream practice. It is not at present - despite 10 years of shady marketing techniques and scare-the-public tactics of Aspect Medical. Until then, the majority of us don't believe in it and don't use it.

The incidence of awareness in noncardiac and nonob cases is 0.2% (Anesthesia, 1991). It is much higher in ob, cardiac, and trauma surgeries. At that rate it amounts to at least 40000 pt's at day. Luckily most of the patients who experience awareness do not also experience recall. So they experienced all the suffering at the time but don't remember it afterwards.

How is it determined that a pt. has had awareness when they have no recall of it?

Many of the accounts I hear from pts (a good example is the tkr in one of the above posts) are examples of awareness during a mac case, not general. That could be partially resolved with education and better explanations to the patients about the type of anesthesia they are about to receive.

+ Add a Comment